Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Student Discount vs Refurbished Macbook
- Thread starter jmack549
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
like everyone else has already said and probably will all agree that you should just get the new one!
Actually, I have yet to hear of anyone being dissatisfied with any of the Apple refurbs (dozens of people, including 4 myself). They test them pretty thoroughly before selling them.
I would always get the newer model though.
Hi, I just saw this thread. I'm in a similar position, my issue is the $949 refurb MB 2.0, 80GB with superdrive vs the student discount new MB (although same speed/spec) $999 with combo drive. I'm sure the new machine is better with the graphics card/available RAM, but I really want that superdrive. Any thoughts on this?
I would say just go with the mid-end macbook. It is a little more expensive, but you get the superdrive, an extra .2 Ghz of processor speed which may not sound like much but makes a pretty significant difference, and you get a 120GB hard drive instead of 80GB which is pretty big since you will go through 80GB pretty fast. If you want your macbook to last longer, in my opinion just save up an extra $200 and get a new mid-range one.
If you plan on this laptop being your primary computer for the next 5 years, get the newest model. If not and you need the superdrive for serious reasons, get the refurb. Check out a thread I made on the same topic, btw.
I have a refurb MBP. Purchased in April. It's awesome -- no complaints.
Agreed. As I said earlier, it's worth it for the small price difference. The new MB is the better choice in this case.
Depends. I bought a student discount 15" 2.16ghz MacBook Pro in March mainly because I also wanted Final Cut Express preinstalled for an extra $100 (had I gotten a refurb, it would have cost more for FCE).
But a couple weeks ago, I just bought a 15" 2.2ghz MCP for $1699 (refurb) vs. $1799 new. I saved a Hundred there. Plus, I saved another $60 for rebate going with a business agent:
http://otechs.com/rebate
So in that case, it was worth it to go with refurb to save $160.
the person on this board to PM for more info on this is techound1.
But a couple weeks ago, I just bought a 15" 2.2ghz MCP for $1699 (refurb) vs. $1799 new. I saved a Hundred there. Plus, I saved another $60 for rebate going with a business agent:
http://otechs.com/rebate
So in that case, it was worth it to go with refurb to save $160.
the person on this board to PM for more info on this is techound1.
Thanks, this makes sense. The thing is I'm already stretching just to afford the $1000 for the earlier model. I'm sure the newer machines are great and will probably hold thier value reallywell, but the truth is I don't need the newer machine for what I want to do. I'm just going to be recording audio, word processing and other basic stuff- no gaming or anything. I'm sure the faster frontside buss would help with the audio, but otherwise...
Refurb are great but the price difference is so small in this case, I'd definitely go for the new one ..
Thanks, this makes sense. The thing is I'm already stretching just to afford the $1000 for the earlier model. I'm sure the newer machines are great and will probably hold thier value reallywell, but the truth is I don't need the newer machine for what I want to do. I'm just going to be recording audio, word processing and other basic stuff- no gaming or anything. I'm sure the faster frontside buss would help with the audio, but otherwise...
I am in the same position as you. I've been hunting down Apple gift cards and Apple iPhone rebates on Craigslist, buying them up for less than face value from the sellers. It's a giant hassle, but at least I can save a pretty fair amount.