The genius bar would not replace my 3gs with a cracked back plastic.
they said the problem was resolved after the 3g with a different polymer. I think the genius bar is full of ***t.
This is the first time i've had a problem with apple for any reason. Bunch of trendy hipsters in there too.
Take it to another apple store if there is one near enough for you. I had different responses from different apple stores for my unable to boot macbook pro. The first one told me they would need to charge 100 dollars to run a program to find the problem and fix the problem. I passed. 2nd store said the problem was a graphics chip that Apple posted as an extended warranty for some macbook pros (which mine qualified). So I got everything fixed on my macbook pro free of charge due to that.
It appears some geniuses are more genius than others. Seriously, they should get rid of the title "genius".
No, some of them are just dumber than others. These days, they don't even know what Automator is and they have no understanding of Terminal. But hell, they can create a playlist fast!
Was your MBP the first unibody with the faulty graphics? I have one of these but I don't tend to switch for the 9600. That slot is just too rare not to have it...