Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I'm making a point, I couldn't care less either way. I have a 2011 user-serviceable iMac and even with my high technical knowledge all I wanted to do is upgrade the ram to 16GB and I did and that was all I wanted to do.

And I doubt customers will walk away from a non-user-servicable iMac. Don't get upset man, the other companies are going to follow suit. Don't think they won't, they will, that have. Almost every decision Apple makes the other companies follow right behind.

Haha, because all the PC vendors are pushing all in ones... and thunderbolt...
I don't know why you think I'm upset. You talk like someone who only follows apple products.

If apple offered a midrange tower iMac sales would plummet.
 
After seeing the new faster iMacs in a slimmer body at the Apple store this scene from Aladdin immediately came to mind:

"PHENOMENAL COSMIC POWER! itty bitty living space"

(they are seriously crazy thin)
 

Attachments

  • ittybittylivingspace.jpg
    ittybittylivingspace.jpg
    71.4 KB · Views: 81
Personal experience and anecdotal evidence from others. It appears to be up to the Apple employee inspecting the machine. Outcomes appear random. Like I said, they may look the other way if you don't screw anything up.

My readings on this topic is that the warranty is not voided. Some Apple store personnel may initially balk at coverage but will no be able to void the warranty unless the consumer damaged the computer in the process of upgrading.

----------



Apparently, he did not need to remove the logic board.

Several repair videos showed the logic board being removed - the third image you posted showed the ram but I wonder how you release it with such little access?
 
Haha, because all the PC vendors are pushing all in ones... and thunderbolt...

I did in fact say, "almost" every decision Apple makes other companies follow suit and it is true. Also what's true is every PC company has an AIO that they are trying to push hard to grab iMac sales. Heck, Sony doesn't even make tower PC's anymore, all they have are AIO's and laptops.

So you're saying I'm wrong in regards to tablets going viral after the iPad's success? So are you saying I'm wrong that Ultrabooks went viral after the Macbook Air's success? So are saying that other companies didn't remove the floppy drive after the success of the first iMac not having one?
So are you saying that I'm wrong that PC companies aren't beginning to make laptops without optical drives?
 
Here's the deal, iFixit MAKES MONEY from repairing machines and trying to convince users they too can repair crap if they purchase their tools. So their "3 out of 10" is basically just their profit margins going down. Of course they are going to be "disappointed..."

I'm not sure if they missed it, but this is an ALL IN ONE machine, which by their very nature aren't generally easy to bust open and start swapping things out.

Besides, by the time you are in dire need of upgrading the CPU, Intel switches sockets on ya.

In short, it's cool to see how they are put together, but iFixit's "ratings" are dumb when done on devices like this, Apple or not.

would you pay for entire display assembly if you accidentally crack ur front screen glass?
not to mention other common failures in iMac (if you familiar with iMac, u understand what i mean)
 
I don't disagree essentially, but bear in mind that we are amidst a worldwide financial crises. Very few people even in the west, let alone the millions starving around the globe, can afford the prices apple charge for repairs and components. Besides something needing to be upgradable, it also has to be repairable. :) And while most people won't open up their imac I am sure most of us have a friend or a family member that's a handy person who'll tweak or do a little repair the cheap way for us when we need it.

Apple is sculpting a premium consumer market that supposedly likes thin and sealed products, with custom ports, and soldered memories (all premium from apple only of course), and custom ssds where industry standards would fit (case in point the ample room in the 13" rmbp where apple is sticking a flash module engolfed in rubber with tons of wasted space). There's planned obsolescence too, another major chapter too long to discuss here.

Their only motivation for that is more, and more, EASY profit, at HUGE margins, far, far wider than anyone in an industry with razor thin margins and a lot of very big players routinely going under, or being on the verge to do so, from sharp, to pioneer, to nokia, to blackberrry etc. etc. Now, there's nothing wrong with a company wanting more profits, but there's a fine line and a lot of question marks as to what extent they are taking advantage of their customers to get to them. I think they are, and I think they are shameless at doing so. And it's not only hardware, it's also for example how they went about colluding with book publishers to get to this market as well, causing an unprecedented increase in ebook prices for the average consumer. They have clout, they are hip, they are a status symbol in many parts of the world, and they have carved out a way of doing things. That doesn't mean their way of doing things won't backfire at some point.

The market of the premium consumer THEY are carving out, is in THEIR opinion not interested in upgrading, or rather in being denied the right to uprade or repair yourself, or have a friend do it, and do so cheaply, and to extend the life of your device thus. That's their opinion. Of course that's the way they can make the most money too. If I were Tim Cook I wouldn't be taking this route, I d be aware that I 've been overcharging for way too long, and that times and fashions change all the time, and I 'd offer my customers more choice, less lock in, more functionality, less pointless styling.

Then. Don't. Buy. It.

There is NO fine line, it's supply and demand. If enough people stopped buying their products because they are not repairable, they would change.

You are being denied nothing, they are not the only option, just apparently the one that you want but aren't happy with.

Then. Don't. Buy. It.

It is apparent that you are not the premium consumer THEY are carving out, as if they had the ability to force this market upon you, which is laughable.

I get that people are disappointed, but comments like yours just sound like more of the entitlement generation who feels they have been wronged because they didn't get what they wanted. It's sad really.
 
re: Mac Pro doesn't count?

I completely get your point, but I feel like I have to defend the Mac Pro a bit here too. I elected to buy not just 1, but 2 of them over the years, because they've been such good workhorse machines for me.

Your claim that they don't count because they're "insane overkill" and don't get updated often is pretty suspect, IMO. Did you ever consider that maybe they go so long between major upgrades because their buyers don't feel like they NEED a new system for that long?

That's certainly been the case for me. I bought a 2006 Mac Pro when they were brand new and it was so expensive I had to take out a small loan for the thing. But you know what? I used it constantly until earlier this year, when I turned around and resold it and STILL got more resale value out of it than the price Dell asks for a typical brand new desktop right now.

It's not "overkill" if you're buying for the long haul. It's assurance that you're investing in a system that's good enough so you won't have to go through backing up all your data on it, wiping the drive to prep it for resale, finding a buyer, buying a new Mac, and reloading/restoring all your stuff to it every 2 or 3 years!


Fair enough, but you act like there's a choice. Apple doesn't have a regular, user-serviceable desktop. The Mac Pro doesn't count, because it's an insane overkill, has an astronomical cost, and only gets updated every 7 years. The Mac Mini would be nice, if it had a video card, a 512GB SSD plus a couple of HDDs. The case would have to be a little larger for that. But such a product doesn't exist. Something the size of an Xbox, which we could easily upgrade to replace the memory, the video board and the drives. Even if it only supported a handful of Apple-approved video cards.
 
Ahhh... more self-righteous and self-serving indignation from the iFixit folks. ;)

Yeah, the OUTRAGE of people who don't approve of a desktop computer designed to be thrown away after 2.5 years.

How dare they think any consumer product should last longer than that!!!

I'm sure you look at us pathetic folks who still drive cars that are 4, 5, or even 8 years old as self-righteous and self serving as well.
 
I'm a little behind I guess but I didn't realize the optical drive was gone from the new iMac. I did just get a new Macbook Pro Retina at work and was thinking "at least I can still use my iMac at home to burn discs when needed."

The floppy was ready to die when Apple quit offering them. However, the DVD refuses to die mainly because of horrible digital content distribution.

We rent at Redbox all the time and I cannot really believe that it is happening. It is almost 2013 and the best and most economical way to watch the movie you want is to drive down to Walgreens and rent a friggin disc from a kiosk and then return it the next day.

Netflix streaming is economical but has poor offerings. iTunes has better offerings (although far from perfect) but a $5 digital rental is not a good deal in my mind.
 
Here's the deal, iFixit MAKES MONEY from repairing machines and trying to convince users they too can repair crap if they purchase their tools. So their "3 out of 10" is basically just their profit margins going down. Of course they are going to be "disappointed..."

I'm not sure if they missed it, but this is an ALL IN ONE machine, which by their very nature aren't generally easy to bust open and start swapping things out.

Besides, by the time you are in dire need of upgrading the CPU, Intel switches sockets on ya.

In short, it's cool to see how they are put together, but iFixit's "ratings" are dumb when done on devices like this, Apple or not.
Way to apologize for Apple. And there's a difference between iFixit having a stake in repairability, and for them to be not be trustworthy because of it. They have a rating system for repairability, and I don't see any bias in their rating. If a computer is hard to repair like the iMac, or therMBP, then they will get a low score. And that's the way it should be.
 
I have to ask because I ask every time--who gives a **** what iFixit thinks other than iFixit? Why is their opinion even relevant? Take the thing to an Apple store--problem solved.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
o claim that people complaining about repairability ( eg to throw some more ram in you have to cross your heart and play strip poker for a few hours with the imac so you can pretty much take everything out and go at the very backside of the mobo to get to it) are those who 'd have never done any repairs to it is simply bonkers.

I pop open every one of my computers, iPhones, etc. The "repairability" score is a good indication of how long the process takes. The walkthroughs they do are what really matters.

Besides that, opening a device is opening a device. Some are easier than others. In a PC I'm more likely to slice open my hand, because they don't polish the steel edges. With a Mac, I'm more likely to lose a screw.

Come on people, disassembly isn't rocket science. Be careful, go slowly, and have a good process for keeping track of what part goes where during reassembly. Oh, and keep kids/cats out of the room.
 
Not really, I am not that into these types of websites to be honest, I like more tech news and less gadgety news, I might go for the uk site the register for example, but engadget has some respectability at least, gizmodo too, not too bad... the verge is simply unbearable in the way they suck up to apple, and the fanboism that ensues, I for once can't stomach it...:)

Gizmodo? Oy! I just lost ALL respect for you. :D
 
People have spoken with their wallets that the majority of people buying apple products put a low priority of repairability
That goes hand & hand with Apples target market. The USA leads when it comes to tolerant consumers living in a throwaway society. The concept of "maintenance & repair" has no appeal to the average consumer.

Rather than do the math, manage their finances & be fiscally sound. It's much more fashionable to buy, buy, buy. Amassing debt, keeping the credit card companies fat, and having expensive possessions they only think they own.

----------

it's fantastic thing, Steve Jobs now tossing and turning in his grave in shame.

No worries. The consummate narcissist, he knew no shame.
 
i wouldn't mind not having user serviceable access to memory and hard drives if the machine cost 400 bucks and it got tossed after three years if need necessitated.
but for machines costing over 1200, over 2K?? f.u. mang, it should be upgradable
 
I have to ask because I ask every time--who gives a **** what iFixit thinks other than iFixit? Why is their opinion even relevant? Take the thing to an Apple store--problem solved.

Ugh I rather go into wal-mart on black friday than go into an Apple store any day of the year. Horrible experience. I can't see what is so fascinating about the same stuff sitting on shelves for years and years. Same style iphone, everyone has seen an ipad by now. Reminds me of the walking dead in a sense. Eyes look the same LOL

A Sony store makes more sense to be crowded since they have so much different gear.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Then. Don't. Buy. It.

There is NO fine line, it's supply and demand. If enough people stopped buying their products because they are not repairable, they would change.

You are being denied nothing, they are not the only option, just apparently the one that you want but aren't happy with.

Then. Don't. Buy. It.

It is apparent that you are not the premium consumer THEY are carving out, as if they had the ability to force this market upon you, which is laughable.

I get that people are disappointed, but comments like yours just sound like more of the entitlement generation who feels they have been wronged because they didn't get what they wanted. It's sad really.

What's sad is that people can put up with being charged an extra +$450 for the benefit of apple sticking a $60 (retail) component in a socket and apple has the audacity to force upon unknowing customers hard drive speeds circa 2003 in 2013 instead of sticking a $30 32gb flash module there for the os and apps to run at proper speeds.

The "then don't buy it" argument doesn't hold ground, I am into their ecosystem deep I need to buy a mac, I'll HAVE to buy it, and they will get their 400% margin off of me, or I ll have to go with the mini that in their infinite wisdom no longer has a discrete gpu (what the hell did they do THAT for), so I am getting effed either way.

Thanks apple. :rolleyes::apple:
 
When you have AppleCare, why bother repairing it yourself? One of the key advantages in getting a Mac is that it isn't some PC you either have to try to fix yourself or go thru hell to get support for it.

Why not put Apple in control over your total life, as well? Let Apple decide if you deserve a meal today, by buying an AppleFoodCare. I mean, if you let Apple decide it, they will make sure your meal is up to standard, before approving it, right? Must only be good for you?
 
my 2007 imac also suffered the same fate w/ the front glass. i was drunk and watching a football game. my team lost and tossed my garbage can to the tv (an old crt) but ricocheted and hit the 20" imac. the tv had no scratches but the imac's front glass broke. the lcd inside was spared. and the penalty for this dumb act was only $60. i bet that if this happened to the new model, that the lcd would have broken.


But I also bet NORMAL people have enough self control not to throw things such as trash cans at their TVs. A company can't build in tolerance points for drunk/angry-because-football-team-lost nights....
 
I'm a little behind I guess but I didn't realize the optical drive was gone from the new iMac. I did just get a new Macbook Pro Retina at work and was thinking "at least I can still use my iMac at home to burn discs when needed."

The floppy was ready to die when Apple quit offering them. However, the DVD refuses to die mainly because of horrible digital content distribution.

We rent at Redbox all the time and I cannot really believe that it is happening. It is almost 2013 and the best and most economical way to watch the movie you want is to drive down to Walgreens and rent a friggin disc from a kiosk and then return it the next day.

Netflix streaming is economical but has poor offerings. iTunes has better offerings (although far from perfect) but a $5 digital rental is not a good deal in my mind.

Apples own external Disc Drive that is portable (ANY iMac is NOT) is plentiful at Best Buy. $69.

I have a Mac Pro, a brand new Mac Mini -- iPhones, iPads, Apple TV - I myself haven't used the built in disc drive on my Pro literally in months. This a TREND in technology, clearly not Apples doing. Geez. God the childish complaints. I bet these same people populated the anti Blu ray forums and even the pro Blu ray people that still can't accept it itself was just a bridge format and it too is going to fade fast.

Some perspective -- these forums are for a small demographic of core customers that sometimes let their passions get the best of them. While I certainly am a core customer and very passionate about Apples ecosystem, I have no desire whatsoever to open up an iMac and cry hurt cuz of its production. I guess I'm so smart that if I'm so concerned about a computers RAM etc, I'd just make sure I ordered the make and model that fit my needs, PERIOD. I mean, it's not like Apple itself offers only one config, c'mon. Same stupid reason you'd *think* that the built in speakers should be THX quality -- bahaaaahahahahahahha.

Reality Check -- Apple TV streams all your audio from your iMac to your home theater system, why on earth would anyone expect dynamic sound out of a monitor? Personally OR professionally.?...!!!!
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.