I was about to buy one, but ended up going with the typical Tech 21 case because I preffer the slightly opaque plastic and odly the Orange bands over the typical solid black like other cases. I see your point about the finger prints though.
I got a tactical first. I liked the case a lot, but found the buttons very hard to push. Took a chance and got a classic check. The buttons are much easier to push, and I actually prefer the smooth TPU finish.