Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Away goals rule: I think (correct me if I'm wrong) the rule was introduced to prevent away teams from parking the bus. But now it has the opposite effect: home teams are terrified to concede and often play defensively, accepting a (preferably scoreless) draw so they can go nick a goal in the away leg and win the tie. It hasn't solved any problem, merely shifted it elsewhere.

Yep, that's right. But Dortmund parked a bus yesterday? Must have seen a different game then. Arsenal first leg partly yes though, if memory serves me well. But is that the norm? It's happening in most of the important games with smart teams involved anyway - whoever concedes first has a huge problem.

There are incredible stupid rules made up by FIFA/UEFA but this isn't one of them imho. But I didn't follow football prior to this rule so I'm prolly biased. ;)
 
More MLS news: I completely forgot to announce the big news in Columbus: the Crew have a new manager in former USA defender (and European journeyman) Gregg Berhalter. Berhalter was recently fired by Hammarby in Sweden after becoming the first American to manage in Europe (saw that claim in several news articles but haven't checked it, and doubt it, frankly. Surely another American has managed in Europe somewhere at some point?). He played a season with Crystal Palace over 10 years ago, so keen-eyed Palace fans might recognize him. He spent most of his professional career in Germany and the Netherlands.

I'm a bit pessimistic about the appointment. Columbus' new owner has decided to dump the role of technical director and give Berhalter broad control over both player recruitment/drafting and managing the senior team. Berhalter allegedly beat out two Columbus legends who had expressed interest in the job - Brad Friedel and Guillermo Barros Schelotto. Bringing in former players to manage often fails (our outgoing manager is an example), but Berhalter's experience is slim and has not yet demonstrated any great ability.

Another announcement was made this week: the retirement of beloved Columbus (and occasional USA) midfielde Eddie Gaven at just 26 years of age. He's been with the Crew for 7 seasons. It's an unusual move, and not due to any injury either - the reasons remain unclear. He's one of those players I'd expected to see playing for us into his 30s, but it was not to be. He was one of our best players over the last few seasons so apart from being sad to see him go on personal level, he leaves a big hole in the roster that will be very hard to fill. Best of luck Eddie! :eek:

Yep, that's right. But Dortmund parked a bus yesterday? Must have seen a different game then. Arsenal first leg partly yes though, if memory serves me well. But is that the norm? It's happening in most of the important games with smart teams involved anyway - whoever concedes first has a huge problem.

There are incredible stupid rules made up by FIFA/UEFA but this isn't one of them imho. But I didn't follow football prior to this rule so I'm prolly biased. ;)

Well, there is a difference between simply parking the bus and playing a truly effective counterattacking game, where the team may seem to sit back for long periods and yet spring into action occasionally with deadly results. I want to say that Dortmund were doing the latter and merely failed to score, rather than the former.
 
Well, there is a difference between simply parking the bus and playing a truly effective counterattacking game, where the team may seem to sit back for long periods and yet spring into action occasionally with deadly results. I want to say that Dortmund were doing the latter and merely failed to score, rather than the former.

So? The argument was that the away goal rule would lead to the home team playing all out defense. But since Dortmund won in London a draw would have been better for them than Arsenal, so all out attack was out of the question as well (plus counter attacking is where Dortmund excels most - especially with Gündogan out for half of the season). I wouldn't say they sat back though Arsenal was defending well combined with bad luck Miki missing the goal first half.
 
So, Spurs get a win…but Sheriff get an away goal. ;)

Another penalty for Spurs as well…

So? The argument was that the away goal rule would lead to the home team playing all out defense. But since Dortmund won in London a draw would have been better for them than Arsenal, so all out attack was out of the question as well (plus counter attacking is where Dortmund excels most - especially with Gündogan out for half of the season). I wouldn't say they sat back though Arsenal was defending well combined with bad luck Miki missing the goal first half.

Oh, I agree - I don't think the Arsenal-Dortmund tie was a good example of why the away goals rule can be lame. This is because both teams are technically very good and thus rarely need to park the bus at all. My comments were more generally directed. The weaker the teams, the more likely they are to try and exploit the away goals rule - or to fear its implications in their home matches.
 
Last edited:
aston-villa.JPG


aston villa 1879

my latest acquisition... anyone ever order from historicalkits.com?

i ordered a large... should fit me or one of my boys... ;)
 
The worst thing about the Chelsea match is that they drew a game they absolutely deserved to lose. They have a much better team than West Brom but played horribly and then flopped for the point. Tsk tsk. :roll eyes:

Fulham are having a really rough season.
 
Whoever is responsible for Southampton's defense should to also be given the job of fixing the roof. They'd have it buttoned up tight in no time.

Southampton, with their impenetrable defense, are now third in the table.

On another note, Newcastle with their second big scalp in two weeks. Krul was imperious but Spurs' weak offense strikes again. This is a season full of upsets.
 
Last edited:
And Sunderland upset City. Massive performance. Played with everything and then some. Wes Brown imperious.

On another note, of course today of all days we lose our best centre back pairings. Hopefully Vermaelen puts in a shift. Flamini's return could not have come at a better time. *phew*.

Hopefully we can take advantage of the weekends results.
 
Image

aston villa 1879

my latest acquisition... anyone ever order from historicalkits.com?

i ordered a large... should fit me or one of my boys... ;)

Great Strip.:)

The big news here is that PSV lost again.

NAC Breda 2 PSV 1

The team and the club in general are in trouble, and the infighting behind the closed doors is not helping.

PSV used to have the image of a friendly family, it’s now more like the Sapranos.;)
 
Our attackers failed to show up today. All flat. United professional.

Another Old Trafford defeat chalked on the board. :rolleyes:

Liverpool will be delighted.
 
^An excellent weekend for Liverpool in terms of results. But, going forward, I don't see us picking up many points from Chelsea, either Mancunian side or Tottenham. Or Southampton for that matter. The top 6 spots are still totally up for grabs and I don't like Liverpool's prospects long-term. Still, as long as we can pummel sides below us in the table it keeps us in the running.

Arsenal must be cursing the name of Van Persie. I know I would be. He was the difference in this match, pure and simple. Arsenal have become a better team since his sale but why did they sell him to a direct league rival? I've said this before but it bears repeating. :eek:

As for the game, I thought Arsenal were criminally hesitant in the box - particularly Giroud and Wilshere. I'm beginning to wonder if Giroud isn't beginning to slump a bit. Too many touches when they should have been shooting. Man Utd missed a couple opportunities too but Arsenal have no excuse for failing to score in this match, and frankly little excuse for not winning given the chances they created. Bendtner. :roll eyes: Even I got a sinking feeling when he stepped on the pitch. Ozil played too many sloppy passes resulting in giveaways.

Rooney had the red mist in front of his eyes, he flagrantly shoved Arsenal players out of bounds at least twice and got away with merely a lecture from the ref. His tackle on Wilshere was laughable. He did a lot of valuable chasing of defenders and was almost the only reason Man Utd spent any amount of time in Arsenal's half.

Had Liverpool faced this Man Utd team earlier in the season we would have been beaten. Man Utd have never lost in the Premier League when they've lead at the half. Will they ever?

EDIT: It's worth pointing out that Arsenal have a fairly lengthy injury list at the moment, and that has to be factored in. But they've been playing so well with the squad they had available it seems unfair to cite that as a major reason for this loss. Still, I think Mertesacker and Rosicky would have made a difference.
 
Last edited:
Even I was flabbergasted by how wasteful they were. Our lack of depth really showed today. We need Walcott and Poldi back badly. If Mertesacker was on the pitch RVP doesn't score. Speaking of RVP, i used to respect him but after today's celebration...not so much. Former Club Captain no less.

I guess Dortmund away took its toll...plus the United juju bug....excuses excuses.

Oh well, still top. But cue pundits lauding United and slagging Arsenal again. As you were I suppose.
 
Last edited:
Oh well cue pundits lauding United and slagging Arsenal again. As you were I suppose.

I am inclined to agree re: Mertesacker. United had few chances and they took one of them; Arsenal had more chances and couldn't put a single one away - it's like the Liverpool match in reverse. Also, Arsenal never attacked up the left. I think this allowed Man Utd to concentrate more resources on the right.

I don't know the origin of the feed I was watching but they were tripping over themselves to be the biggest United admirer, citing all the statistics they could to show how dominant they've been over the years and how they were surely "back" now. :(

We will see what happens at the end of the season, but unfortunately things seem to be slowly shaping themselves back into the Old Order. Please let me be wrong (hang in there Southampton!).
 
Manchester United should have been out of sight before the couple of Sagna crosses, still, not bad given they lost Vidic, Carrick played with an injury, and Rafael is out. Hell, they even did it putting Giggs on instead of Januzaj.

Giroud somehow stays on the pitch, escaping bookings and a penalty.

RVP's celebration; a FU to the Arsenal chanting. Respect indeed.

Cheers,
OW
 
To me today's match just proved that United have some work to do if they want to have a prayer at the title. An under-strenght, tired and maybe even unwell Arsenal made them look better than they really were. Only 1 set-piece the difference in the end. Its rarely been as tight as it was today in recent seasons.

Moyes will need to get 2 or 3 bodies in during the Jan window or else the struggles will continue. No SAF magic this time. Without RVP and Rooney they really are an average team. Titles aren't won on offensive strength alone...as City will gladly testify to.
 
Last edited:
To me today's match just proved that United have some work to do if they want to have a prayer at the title.

I don't want to stick up for Man Utd, but to be fair they might not have to be much better than this to finish in the top three or four, or even challenge for the title. Man City and Spurs are hardly convincing, Chelsea have been hot and cold, Liverpool have obvious weaknesses and nobody is giving Southampton a chance at staying where they are. Not to mention that Everton are solidly if unspectacularly plugging away as well. The bar is set relatively low this season.

There is still plenty of time for teams to go on a run and put distance between themselves and the others. Any of the top 9 teams are still technically in a position to do this. Conversely, any of the top 9 teams could have a big slump that sees them finishing midtable or below.
 
To me today's match just proved that United have some work to do if they want to have a prayer at the title. An under-strenght, tired and maybe even unwell Arsenal made them look better than they really were. Only 1 set-piece the difference in the end. Its rarely been as tight as it was today in recent seasons.

Moyes will need to get 2 or 3 bodies in during the Jan window or else the struggles will continue. No SAF magic this time. Without RVP and Rooney they really are an average team. Titles aren't won on offensive strength alone...as City will gladly testify to.

Arsenal, the only team to play midweek and have injury/availability problems; sounding like Chelsea and Manchester City.

Manchester United aren't the only club in the Top 8 - Top 4: Extended Version - looking to buy in January; as Lord Blackadder mentions, there is weakness throughout the group - could be Wacky Races all the way.

Cheers,
OW
 
The top 6 are all just as terrible as each other in one aspect or another, which makes this season both exciting for the neutral and frustrating for any supporters of the top 6 clubs.

Because you can just see someone will unconvincingly stumble on to the title. And lo and behold United are the most likely since they have the least tough fixture list until Jan whilst everyone else has to play each other.

Like Blackadder says...the writings are on the wall.
 
Great Strip.:)

The big news here is that PSV lost again.

NAC Breda 2 PSV 1

The team and the club in general are in trouble, and the infighting behind the closed doors is not helping.

PSV used to have the image of a friendly family, it’s now more like the Sapranos.;)

o no!

and they were the face of the Eredivisie (sp?) for quite a while...
 
One side-effect of the current state of affairs might be an unusually active January transfer window, as the top 8ish clubs try to plug holes in their lineup and beef up their squads for the run-in. In theory Man City and Chelsea should not have to do this with their huge squads but everyone else might benefit from a signing or two.

Although this cheered me up a little bit :)

The death knell of the theory of nominative determinism.
 
Hmm. I wrote a rather long post just before MacRumors went down that appears to have been lost in the ether. I won't retype it all, but suffice to say that it appears Allam's finally gone and lost it.

He's met with supporter groups, made promises and gone back on them within the space of a fortnight. He's admitted he's done no research into the benefits of changing our name but intends to plough on with it - and in trying to support his argument he's made himself look increasingly foolish. And today he's embarked on a series of interviews on the matter with local and national media - print, radio and TV - in which he's become increasingly incoherent and angry with supporters and in some instances with the interviewers themselves.

It looks like attempts to engage and persuade him have failed, and that we have a fight on our hands.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.