Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Harry Kane has torn his hamstring, and will be out till March. Mourinho, Spurs, and England are all kind of up a creek at this point.

Yes, I read that this evening.

A blow to Kane, and to Spurs, as well as to England and The Special One.

Not so bothered about the Special One, but it is rough for Spurs, England and Kane himself.

And it appears that Pogba has developed an injury in a different part of his ankle to where his previous ankle injury occurred.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
No earth-shattering results in the FA Cup today, though a few Premier League clubs stumbled against lower league opposition. Wolves and Man utd earn themselves an unwanted replay.
 
No earth-shattering results in the FA Cup today, though a few Premier League clubs stumbled against lower league opposition. Wolves and Man utd earn themselves an unwanted replay.
But given this is their only real chance of domestic silverware you’d have thought they’d have made it a priority. Hardly registered a shot on target from what I read. Probably missing Pogba!
 
Pogba has a terminal case of Mino Raiola-itis, which is damaging his career - though not his, nor his superagent's, bank account.

I'm more than ready to move Pogba on. It's better for everyone involved.

And Raiola can take a long walk off a short pier.
 
Columbus Crew SC have broken ground for their new stadium and construction is ramping up. I'm hoping to make a few games this season as it will be the last for MAPFRE (Columbus Crew) Stadium, the first dedicated soccer stadium built in the US in the modern era (the only other one built prior, which still exists but is now a football stadium for a small college in Pennsylvania, was built before WWI).

But given this is their only real chance of domestic silverware you’d have thought they’d have made it a priority. Hardly registered a shot on target from what I read. Probably missing Pogba!

I'd say that Man Utd's priority is finishing fourth - because, let's face it, qualifying for the Champions League is really the second most important "trophy" in England, ahead of both cups. Leicester and Man City seem pretty certain to make the top four, so that leaves one spot for Chelsea, Man Utd, Wolves, Spurs, Arsenal, and perhaps even Sheffield United to fight for. Each of those clubs has had periods of inconsistency, so it could be a very interesting battle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
That’s terrible news. A real blow for England. Not so bothered about Spurs.
Really not bothered about Mourinho!

Having suffered a hamstring injury many years ago, he gets all my sympathy. It will be a slow process to heal.

Disappointed that Man U/Wolves match ended in a tie. I dislike ties, Man U needs to do better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
Harry Kane has a history of both injuries and of healing quickly from injuries; however, I wish him luck in his recovery - Spurs (and England) will certainly miss him, as, even when he recovers, he will take some time to become match fit.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
Watching the Crystal Palace / Derby County cup tie...I really don't want to talk VAR again but Luka Milivojević just got sent off after some handbags with Tom Huddlestone thanks to the heavy hand of VAR.

He and Huddlestone got into a little tussle on the halfway line off the ball, with Huddlestone "kicking" (i.e. a token little tap on) Milivojević, who responded with a "headbutt" (i.e. the faintest movement of the head in Huddlestone's direction). Michael Oliver quite rightly showed both players a yellow for this silly little pantomime "fight," but then we had a long dreary VAR delay which lead to Milivojević's card being upgraded to a red. Total overreaction by the officials and, worse still, a completely needless delay of the match.

Oliver's on-pitch instinct to issue yellows and play on was perfect - and then the VAR review made a mountain out of a molehill. Worse still, not every match today is being monitored by VAR.
 
Harry Kane has a history of both injuries and of healing quickly from injuries; however, I wish him luck in his recovery - Spurs (and England) will certainly miss him, as, even when he recovers, he will take some time to become match fit.
Spurs only managed a draw today. I wonder if a fit HK would have been a different result.
[automerge]1578241181[/automerge]
Watching the Crystal Palace / Derby County cup tie...I really don't want to talk VAR again but Luka Milivojević just got sent off after some handbags with Tom Huddlestone thanks to the heavy hand of VAR.

He and Huddlestone got into a little tussle on the halfway line off the ball, with Huddlestone "kicking" (i.e. a token little tap on) Milivojević, who responded with a "headbutt" (i.e. the faintest movement of the head in Huddlestone's direction). Michael Oliver quite rightly showed both players a yellow for this silly little pantomime "fight," but then we had a long dreary VAR delay which lead to Milivojević's card being upgraded to a red. Total overreaction by the officials and, worse still, a completely needless delay of the match.

Oliver's on-pitch instinct to issue yellows and play on was perfect - and then the VAR review made a mountain out of a molehill. Worse still, not every match today is being monitored by VAR.
I don’t really understand how you can have it at some games not others in the same competition.
VAR is not ending the controversy. It’s creating it. Not what was supposed to happen.
 
An open match at Anfield at halftime, both teams have had some pretty good chances but nobody has been able to finish them. Everton had the better chances and should probably be leading but for a couple good reaction saves by Adrian.

Not happy to see Milner break down after 7 minutes, I hope it's not a tear or anything serious.
 
Indeed. Especially given the number of youngsters he played.

A good way of "blooding" youngsters, and, if things go well, Liverpool may yet end up with a few more trophies by the end of this season.

While the FA Cup may have lost some of its allure in recent years, (something that I, personally, regret) it is still the world's oldest football cup competition, and has a pedigree and tradition some newer competitions lack, which means that winning the Double is still a very impressive achievement - and a very worthy ambition.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Lord Blackadder
Liverpool B get the job done against a strong Everton side with a worldie from Curtis Jones deciding the contest.

It's the best possible result one could expect given the changes to the team, but Liverpool's squad/youth players stepped up and everyone played their part. Everton looked good in the first half but noticeably trailed off in the second, especially after conceding the goal. Liverpool did not have the firepower of its starting front three but were able to move the ball around pretty well and probe Everton's defense for large stretches of the match. Youth players like Larouci, Chirivella, Phillips, Brewster - and of course Jones - all looked comfortable and confident. The Ox made a useful cameo, Origi did a lot of the hard work (helping set up the goal) and more experienced players like Lallana, Gomez, and Adrian kept things tidy. Minanmino looked sharp, though he wasn't able to grab bis debut goal. The only negative was Milner's injury, he is a very important player for Liverpool.

I'm in the enviable position of having little to complain about (at at least until the next match ;) )

EDIT: Forgot to mention Elliot, who once again looked very lively and excited the crowd every time he drove at the Everton defense. Also, a factoid: Curtis Jones had not yet been born the last time Everton won at Anfield.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
Hearing reports that Milner's injury was a hamstring problem. So that's three plus weeks out. Far from ideal for the teams fittest and most flexible player.

Some have argued that Man City's drop in form has been primarily due to injuries (like Laporte's), and there is a lot of truth to that. However Liverpool also have a crowded physio room and are currently heavily relying on the full extent of their squad depth to get by. Some questioned the wisdom of Klopp keeping four center backs around, but we've used them all and then some.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
Hearing reports that Milner's injury was a hamstring problem. So that's three plus weeks out. Far from ideal for the teams fittest and most flexible player.

Some have argued that Man City's drop in form has been primarily due to injuries (like Laporte's), and there is a lot of truth to that. However Liverpool also have a crowded physio room and are currently heavily relying on the full extent of their squad depth to get by. Some questioned the wisdom of Klopp keeping four center backs around, but we've used them all and then some.

Very unfortunate for Milner and he is a fine player.

However, I would be curious to see stats for injuries and teams with a view to examining whether these can be co-related to the stye or type of football currently being played by some teams.

There is little doubt that - at he very top - players are paid better than ever, have extraordinary resources (training, etc) at their disposal, and receive incredible support from the back room staff, not least medical specialists.

Likewise, there seems little doubt that the very top teams - Manchester City, Leicester, Liverpool - have transformed standards of physical fitness in recent years, (and others may well need to catch up somewhat, yes, Arsenal, I'm looking at you), and, in addition to that, have - with their high pressing games - demanded much more by way of movement, pace, speed of mental and physical reactions and decision making, space covered, from their players in turn.

Nevertheless, one wonders whether this - together with a heavy fixtures list, and the sheer unpleasantness of winter - is not finally taking something of a toll from some players.
 
Nevertheless, one wonders whether this - together with a heavy fixtures list, and the sheer unpleasantness of winter - is not finally taking something of a toll from some players.

There is one fixed factor in all of this, and that is the human body. Sports science has revolutionized football and raised the overall health, endurance, speed, strength, and even mental sharpness of athletes, while shortening recovery times and reducing the severity and consequences of most injuries. However, there is still a upper limit to how much elite-level football a human can endure before the quality of their play drops off and they eventually break down physically and mentally. The current football calendar has arguably already exceeded this threshold for most professional athletes.

There is no limit to the growth ambitions of governing bodies, club owners, sponsors, and TV companies. But there is a limit to the amount of football players can actually play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.