I've now tried out 4 cases for my iphone 5. Otterbox commuter and defender, incipio edge pro and seidio obex (most recently) Commuter- I liked the case until I went to work with it and all the dust started to accumulate on the case (more specifically the silicone) which gave it a faded/brown dirty look which I hate! Defender- hated the screen protector from the start so I pushed it out, then a new problem arised, the case was full of dust. Edge pro- I thought maybe I didn't need such a protective case so I tried this case out. Buttons were hard to push and it scratches for nothing. Obex- like the case but it never did snap together right. The sound quality is awful and it doesn't fit on my 30 pin adapter for a docking station, I will be sending it back!!! I've realized because of what I put my phone through at work I need a highly protective case, not necessarily waterproof though. I'm picky with screen protectors that's a major factor when looking at a case for me also I need one that will fit with the adapter for my docking station. Any suggestions?? been looking at the griffin survivor but I'm open to opinions!