conmee
macrumors 65816
@DeanCorp @PBG4 Dude @H_D @Matt2012 I know this is an order/delivery thread, but a quick question on 14” M5 Max. I’ve watched/read reviews and it seems like the consensus is that all the M-series Max SoCs in general run too hot for the 14” chassis with throttling especially on sustained workloads. I bought a 16” M5 Pro 64GB (in signature) prior to really ramping up my local AI work. Now I’m considering selling to get the M5 Max 128GB. The M5 Pro is doing reasonably well, especially with qwen3.6 and Gemma 8-bitQuantized 32k context but the 64GB isn’t enough to run 70B models like llama at 8-bit. Also, because I would like to have RAG capability with a lot of work documents, I discovered larger context allocation requires a fair amount of memory in addition to the model itself and then as I add any agents/tools to the mix (along with daily apps I use) this further taxes memory. I’m actually thinking even 128GB may not be ideal a year from now (for me) and probably should just hold out for an M5 Max or Ultra Studio with 256GB+. Anyhow, just want opinions on the 14” M5 Max. How is prompt processing, time to first token, and token/sec with the extra memory bandwidth? Pretty sure you’re all going to chime in that it runs extremely hot and throttles but wanted some real world experiences not just professional reviewers. I saw Notebookcheck’s review but I also saw a couple reviews on YouTube that said they had to exchange their 14” M5 Max’s because performance dropped way off and after getting a replacement from Apple the 14” performed like it should within 10-15% of the 16” M5 Max (albeit with lots of fan noise). I probably should either get the 16” M5 Max or wait for the M5 Max Studio but wanted your guys’ impression if you dealt with a 14” M5 Max. Thanks!
Edit: After posting it doesn’t look like a short/quick question. Apologies for the novel!
Edit #2: I also found a reviewer and he said during heavy LLM use the M5 Max produces coil whine which was seconded by some people in comments. Is that true for any M5 Max folks in this thread? I left Lenovo and PCs in 2009 specifically because the MBPs at that time had higher display brightness and no coil whine (along with build quality, OS X, etc). I would not be happy to have coil whine in a $4300-$7000 laptop. Not that I’d hear it given the tinnitus I have in my right ear from 18 years of Intel MBP fans running lol
Edit: After posting it doesn’t look like a short/quick question. Apologies for the novel!
Edit #2: I also found a reviewer and he said during heavy LLM use the M5 Max produces coil whine which was seconded by some people in comments. Is that true for any M5 Max folks in this thread? I left Lenovo and PCs in 2009 specifically because the MBPs at that time had higher display brightness and no coil whine (along with build quality, OS X, etc). I would not be happy to have coil whine in a $4300-$7000 laptop. Not that I’d hear it given the tinnitus I have in my right ear from 18 years of Intel MBP fans running lol
Last edited:


