Team BigMac
Guys, we get recruits from general-interest websites (news sites generally) which also support healthy forum populations. The sponsor sites in turn support us to get free advertising and more regular site traffic - some of those will certainly follow the handy links back to the root news pages.
I can't think of a reason for our various sponsors to continue supporting us on a different team, except Mac pride, and pride does not help pay the server bills.
Here on MacNN, we get an email about once a month from someone who wants to combine all the higher Mac teams. Usually on one project, but sometimes they are ambitious enough to argue combination across all projects. In most cases, the email authors make the mistake of assuming our members will do whatever the team leaders tell them to do. Heh, most of the MacNN members have never posted in our team forum ... some may not have even found our forums.
My reply is always much the same, a link to our team forum and the suggestion that they present their reasoning to our members. So far, not one emailer has followed through. We've discussed it a few times ourselves like you are here, and nothing has come of that either.
On mature teams, most members are inactive. They crunched for a time, got bored, and moved on. Without a general website and forums to supply a steady supply of new members, a team will gradually die off. If we jump off to found our BigMac team, we also need to build our own site - but each major Mac team already has one. It would cost a ton of money, steady attention to news content probably, and would just get us competing with our current sponsors for banner ad bucks and active members.
My opinion is that only Apple could set something like that up. There are a few problems though...
- They don't seem to be interested. The Apple Fold team has fallen out of the Top 100 because Apple didn't do anything to continue interest. There was the one article, and that was it. The team lasted ~6 months before wilting away.
- Even if Apple got interested, they have a control attitude that I would not care to be under. Post something not-so-complimentary in their support forums, and start the stopwatch. Your post/thread will vanish pretty quickly. Our current sponsors are far more tolerant of criticism, and by extension, all other forms of free speech.
I do not see how this could get set up successfully unless someone wanted to spend a bunch of real money on it. And I do not see how it could be continued at all even if it got started.
If you want to take a crack at the reasoning, feel free to hit our
team forum and talk our members into it. You will more than likely be taken for a spy, trying to recruit for macrumors. I'd expect the same to apply on MacAddict and MacOSX forums if you tried those instead, but if you can present a good enough arguement, who knows where it will go.