Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The Max is a great phone...I just don't see it as much of an upgrade over the X unless you are heavy into watching videos/TV content. I played with one for about an hour at the store and here's what I observed:
  1. It's horrible in landscape mode. App Store, Home App, Music doesn't support landscape so it basically makes it a portrait only phone. I hated having to switch back and forth on my 7+ so I just locked it in Portrait.
  2. Given #1, the content differences between the two weren't "glaring" enough for me to upgrade. Sure possibly 1-2 more "lines" or rows of data or text but not enough for me
  3. Given #2, a lot of apps aren't optimized yet so just look like bloated X apps. I know this will change but given the number of apps that don't even support the X it won't be universal.
  4. Given #1, it's horrible for one-handed use. I absolutely love being able to use my X one handed. I normally use my X naked except for few times I'll use a case when around a lot of kids and it's still great one handed.
  5. The so called camera improvements just weren't there in my small sample. The photos on my X that washed out certain lit spots could be eliminated easily by forcing HDR on (I have Auto-HDR turned off for this reason). Once I did that, the differences weren't as glaring. I've used my X on two different vacations this year and took some amazing pictures and given my small sample size (about 10 pictures) I didn't see it. I even showed them to a few people and they couldn't see differences. Granted there wasn't a large sample of lighting differences but the lighting I use were ones that the X normally struggled.
  6. Just didn't see any speed differences. Didn't test WIFI but just usage. Switch apps, opening, etc there was no noticeable difference. Heck, my wife and son's iPhone 7s fly now on iOS12.
At the end of the day those issues I had confirmed that I won't be upgrading from my X.
 
If the iPhone is So great.

Why can’t I enable Haptic keyboard vibration?

Or why can’t I silent those Amber Alerts ?

I like to Hear typing sound on the Keyboard why can’t the iPhone set anything but 20% Volume for Keyboard Sounds ?

Why does pressing the Display off button on the right side of the XsMAX which I’ve used now for 2 weeks end the call when pressed. ?

Here the thing plain and simple these devices MUST be a Phone First. And in every way my S8 Plus is a better PHONE. Than the XsMAX.
In terms of Making and Receiving calls and Data.

Not happy return it. Simple as that. There are plenty of phone choices out there.
 
Have to finally cave in and wave goodbye to the bigger screen as my 14day deadline looms. The brick that is only just bigger but isn't more functional just isn't worthwhile over the X or XS. With my flip flopping I sound like a politician but locking in final answer. The Max was returned this morning. Hopefully the ipad gets a better update.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jimmy_uk
I questioned the size originally, but have since adjusted. I am not sure if I see any real advantage regarding the UI though. I'll hold onto it and see what Apple does with iOS 13. If I don't see major software improvements for the larger devices, I'll likely revert back to the 5.8.
 
The iPhone XS Max is the worst iPhone ever to me. I want my old iPhone 7 back, that was the last good iPhone IMO. There’s just far too many issues with the new phones and Apple has totally dropped the ball on quality control. :(
 
If the iPhone is So great.

Why can’t I enable Haptic keyboard vibration?

Or why can’t I silent those Amber Alerts ?

I like to Hear typing sound on the Keyboard why can’t the iPhone set anything but 20% Volume for Keyboard Sounds ?

Why does pressing the Display off button on the right side of the XsMAX which I’ve used now for 2 weeks end the call when pressed. ?

Here the thing plain and simple these devices MUST be a Phone First. And in every way my S8 Plus is a better PHONE. Than the XsMAX.
In terms of Making and Receiving calls and Data.
It sounds like you need to get a little more familiar with your phone or just flat out google these "problems". For instance, you can easily turn off amber alerts in settings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: akash.nu
6 plus is way lighter than the Max.

And the 8 plus was already a brick.

In Fairness, the XS Max is only 6 g heavier over the iPhone 8 Plus, so both phones theoretically aren’t that much difference in terms of weight. I wouldn’t use the iPhone 6 Plus as an example, considering the 6 Plus didn’t include a glass back and stainless steel bands either.
 
There's something about the iPhone XS Max. It's the same as my other iPhones, but yet different.

I've owed all of the iPhones since the 3GS, with the exception of the iPhone 7. My favorite iPhones of all time have been the iPhone 4S and the iPhone 6S. Now the top place for best iPhone of all time is the iPhone XS Max. This phone is perfect.

My previous phone was the iPhone X. It was the phone I had been waiting for, or so I had thought. Unfortunately, my experience with the iPhone X wasn't a great one. I've wiped and reset the phone more times than I care to count. Apple couldn't, or wouldn't help me. When the iPhone XS Max launched, I couldn't leave the X behind fast enough.

The Screen
My jaw dropped. The screen is huge and not in a distracting way. It's absolutely beautiful. I didn’t see the big deal about OLED on the iPhone X. I thought it looked the same as my LCD based 6S Plus. With the XS Max, I see what the hype was about.

Colors are properly saturated, vibrant, whites are whites, and blacks are blacks on the 6.5” inch canvas. There’s so much more room to process photos, view videos, and create movies. I don’t know anything about the science behind all this, but this has to be the best screen in a smartphone ever. I love looking at this thing.

I loved the size of the "Plus" phones. I got the X because I could have the same screen size, yet in a smaller package. That was a mistake. It felt too small to me. It was also too narrow. The XS Max fits perfectly in my hand.

The Cameras
When I first got my iPhone X, I went out and explored Galveston Island and Moody Gardens to get "sample" photos. I was amazed at the quality. I had just came from the iPhone 6S, so the camera improvements were noticed. The top feature I was eager to see was the "portrait mode". It worked. Sometimes. It needed more work, especially when compared to The Pixel 2.

Portrait Mode would simply over compensate its bokeh effect. It couldn't tell the subject from the background and thus, you would get unnatural looking blur. Understandably, one can't expect bokeh quality you would get from a DSLR, but for a smartphone, when the effect worked, it worked pretty well.

The iPhone XS Max now allows me to control the bokeh effect by changing the aperture variable after taking the shot. So when they iPhone gets it wrong I can change a few settings and get it right.

Exposure is greatly improved as well. Blown highlights were a problem for me on the X, despite its supposed improvements. With the new processing algorithms Apple uses in the XS, photos are more well controlled and have greater dynamic range. Having a clean shot is crucial since I usually put my photos through some type of post processing.

Photos are clear. Low light performance is excellent. Perhaps the photos look "too digital" with the Smart HDR feature (sometimes I want the shadows to be shadows), but what I do know I'll be shooting with my iPhone more and more instead of taking along by Sony RX100 V.

Connectivity
I will tell anyone who will listen, that my iPhone X has connectivity issues. It was slow on AT&T's LTE network. I didn't get any reception in my office building. My phone basically didn't work or worked slowly unless I was using it during off peak hours or on wi-fi.

All of that is gone now. I can get reception in my office, although not as fast as I would like, but I don't have to step outside anytime I need to use my phone.
AT&T LTE is what it is. I get variable speeds depending on what time of day it is and where I am in the city, but now it's more consistent. My previous phone simply didn't function with a weak signal. It was so bad that I vowed that I'd make sure my next iPhone had a Qualcomm chip in it (my X was an AT&T model that had an Intel modem). When I heard that Apple was going Intel only for modems in these iPhones, my heart sank. I was looking to switch carriers in order to have a Qualcomm modem in my iPhone X. All of those fears have been put to rest. The connection is reliable.

Consistent and reliable connectivity shouldn't even be a feature to be discussed, but there was clearly something wrong with my X. Now I see the reason the XS added more antennas. Apple will never admit it, but the XS fixed those short comings with adding more antennas.

Battery Life
I'm back to all day battery life folks. I take my phone off the charger at 4:30am to hit the gym. At 10pm, it's back on the wireless charger with 15% battery life. Days of heavy usage, I can top off a charge on my 30 minute drive on the way home from work.

My X would need to hit the charger about 2pm consistently. Didn't matter if it was iOS 11 or iOS 12. It was such a problem, I bought a cheaper wireless cradle for my office desk. I still don't know what the deal was, according to Apple, the phone was one. 11 months in, the batter life was 90%.

iOS 12
You can have the best looking phone with all the latest and greatest hardware in the world, but none of that matters if the operating system is not up to par. Much of my experience of the iPhone X was due to iOS 11. That had to be the most unpolished iOS ever.

All of the issues I had with iOS 11 are gone with iOS12. Everything is smoother, silky, and buttery. Animations are great. The calculator app works. I don't get random reboots or home screen re-springs. Apps don't seem to crash.

The only quip I have with iOS 12 is some apps don't render properly for the new screen size. This is really on the developers to fix and I'm sure they will in due time.

Again, I have to be cliche: This is the best iPhone ever. It literally just works.
As much as I love my Max at it's best of all iPhones in the past, my dream iPhone would be to still have the same form factor as the X or Xs (non Max) with the same width of the Max display. Hopefully next year with infinity display like the Galaxies.
 
iPhone Xs Max sure is the best phone I've had in a long while. 1st was the very 1st iPhone in 2007, and then the iPhone 4, iPhone 5, and then the iPhone 6 Plus, now the iPhone Xs Max! These are the very best models Apple has ever made.
 
What do you mean?! iPhone 6 does have all of those features.

Yeah, I should have those features but the phone is so old and beat up they don’t work - so while I had great hope for the max, now I’m back to a substandard phone while I wait for the xr...
 
I would agree that it is the best phone ever if only it wasn't killing my eyes.

You need to return this. Go for the XR.
Note: All this talk of eye strain has actually made me paranoid. With something like this, I'm thinking suggestion can get to anyone. Something about the eye muscles.
But, I had the X, and although the screen was extremely vivid (which could in itself, maybe cause fatigue ), I survived (until I lost it, that is :D

The problem is, this extremely rare minority, comes here with their lament (justifiable of course), but it has that effect. You might imagine its 50/50, or a lottery. As a matter of fact, how would we even know really?

This is why I love this forum :)
 
Last edited:
You need to return this. Go for the XR.

Note: All this talk of eye strain has actually made me paranoid. With something like this, I'm thinking suggestion can get to anyone. Something about the eye muscles.
But, I had the X, and although the screen was extremely vivid (which could in itself, maybe cause fatigue ), I survived (until I lost it, that is :D

The problem is, this extremely rare minority, comes here with their lament (justifiable of course), but it has that effect. You might imagine its 50/50, or a lottery. As a matter of fact, how would we even know really?

This is why I love this forum :)

I am not 100% convinced yet that it's the screen and not the FaceID. I will let other report first before I buy yet one more iPhone. I already have an X and Xs Max sitting around that have been used less than a week, don't need another one :D
 
I am not 100% convinced yet that it's the screen and not the FaceID. I will let other report first before I buy yet one more iPhone. I already have an X and Xs Max sitting around that have been used less than a week, don't need another one :D

Then there's the acclamation possibility (hope springs eternal). I'm with you here though, I'm not into returning things i'm unsure of.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.