Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Not sure about cost, but there’s a point to diversifying. Apple has been wanting to diversify production/suppliers for years. Not for political theatre, but hedging for political(and other) turmoil.



Yeah, basically we are seeing the showdown of U.S. and China continuing to play out. How volatile it plays it differs on who is in the White House but people need to understand ultimately no matter which administration is in charge there is a showdown long term. Simply put the U.S. views China as the threat to their power. Anyone paying attention the previous 4 years and beyond should know this. Now Trump does it in a way where it's as volatile as you can think of in your face but ultimately we are in the mist of a power grab and its not just chips. It's everything. Thats why you hear talk about mineral rights, Panama canal and China(which was a topic when Biden was in office). All of this stuff has been in the works for years.





 
Sucks for USA companies. If they manage to get Trump out and the successor lifts the tariffs, it will be for nothing.
 
Let me get this straight. The chips will be made here and then shipped back to China for assembly. And that’s more cost effective?

Or is this all political theatre?
Not theator, accounting, real estate is expensive in Taiwan, so it is cheaper to buy low-cost desert land in AZ and build the plant there. These chips are so small that shipping them around the world is cheap.

Also even if the iPhones are assembled in China, they will have some US components and it will reduce the terrif. A smart accountant might even find a trick that increases the cost of the US-made parts relative to the cost of the phone.

This is like the old story about the glass factory in the old USSR. They were paid based on the square meters of glass produced, so that made the cheapest and thinnest glass they could. When you have silly rules, people will read them carefully to find silly ways to maximize profit. So in this case, building a plant in the AZ desert to supply a factory in China with parts makes sense..
 
Maybe I'm just jaded. It sounds like TSMC is replacing the fabrication machinery with the newer, more advance ones. They don't want to just destroy the old machines. They don't want to sell it to a competitor, so they open up a JV facility where they can dump the old machines. The US factories are the equivalent of Saks OFF 5th, <brand name> Outlet, and <brand name> Factory Store.
 
Plans for this factory started before this administration.
Both parties are appeasing the electorate.

Biden made a turn for manufacturing when the whole democratic party of the 1990 blurted the truth that manufacturing ain't coming back.

The secret sauce of fabs are the TMSC leadership and its top engineers. The U.S. better have planes on standby when and if China invades.
 
EXACTLY.

Another Foxconn in the U.S.A.

A political move to appease the current administration.

The only things I’d be objecting to (if anything at all) would be claims that Trump should get credit for a plant that’s been planned since 2022, or that this in any way currently affects present economic conditions in the country (beyond construction). Being somewhat familiar with the current administration’s penchant for pretentious big wins (like Bondi’s idiotic claim today that Trump has saved 258 million lives in the USA so far this year), I’d like to see his fans be a tad more realistic, that’s all. 😉


I didn't know Biden was in office in May 2020:



----

Media took the story, made it all about Biden a few years later, and there you go.

 
I didn't know Biden was in office in May 2020:



----

Media took the story, made it all about Biden a few years later, and there you go.

I said (as you must know) that my objection was to Trump getting credit for a plant that was announced in 2022, as the Fine Article we’re all talking about says about the second plant. Your links are talking about a plant announced in 2020, which (as we all know) is not 2022 (as the Fine Article is talking about with respect to the second plant, as I have already pointed out).

So I don’t know why you’re quoting me as if you’re replying to me. 🤔 Am I missing something?
 
  • Like
Reactions: TalkieToaster
So what is this fab going to make if it's restricted to 4 nm and larger and won't be operational until 2028?
Probably things like cellular modems and SoCs for lower end embedded systems like HomePods, etc.

It is a false sense of security for the critical devices such as Macs, iPhones, iPads, etc.
 
Meanwhile, Taiwan is forbidding the outsourcing of the newest technology by law: https://9meters.com/technology/new-taiwan-law-blocks-tsmc-from-giving-advanced-chip-tech-to-u-s

“At the heart of this restriction is the newly revised Industrial Innovation Act, which introduces an “N-1” policy. This rule mandates that any semiconductor manufacturing technology deployed abroad must be at least one generation behind what is currently allowed for production in Taiwan.”
How can Taiwan forbid AMSL from exporting their chip tech to other countries?
 
How can Taiwan forbid AMSL from exporting their chip tech to other countries?
Not AMSL, but TSMC. AMSL “only” makes the lithography machines. You can’t replicate what TSMC does just by buying AMSL machinery.
 
I have no idea why people in the comments are objecting to American jobs coming back to America. Thank you Apple and TSMC. Whatever work you are doing in America is giving people jobs.

These jobs weren’t American in the first place. When did people in Ohio or Detroit ever fab chips for Apple? This is just a foreign company subsidizing America’s delicate ego because we can’t handle that we aren’t Super Special Ribbon winners all the time. Chips aside, if a pair of jeans or socks is made in the US and costs 50% more, yet isn’t actually 50% better, why should I be excited about that? Because some dropout didn’t take the time to study and now has beer money?
 
The only things I’d be objecting to (if anything at all) would be claims that Trump should get credit for a plant that’s been planned since 2022, or that this in any way currently affects present economic conditions in the country (beyond construction). Being somewhat familiar with the current administration’s penchant for pretentious big wins (like Bondi’s idiotic claim today that Trump has saved 258 million lives in the USA so far this year), I’d like to see his fans be a tad more realistic, that’s all. 😉

Wow. Bondi's math is pretty amazing. On Tuesday she claimed that seizing 22 million fentanyl pills saved only 119 million lives (⅓ of the US population, at apparently five deaths per pill), and now 258 million lives (¾ of the US). Those pill cutters the druggies are using must be pretty fine.

Well, when you pick your cabinet from Klown Kollege Kadets, these astounding things can happen.

PS of course any reduction in fentanyl trade is welcome, and deaths will be prevented. But come on.
 
Meanwhile, Taiwan is forbidding the outsourcing of the newest technology by law: https://9meters.com/technology/new-taiwan-law-blocks-tsmc-from-giving-advanced-chip-tech-to-u-s

“At the heart of this restriction is the newly revised Industrial Innovation Act, which introduces an “N-1” policy. This rule mandates that any semiconductor manufacturing technology deployed abroad must be at least one generation behind what is currently allowed for production in Taiwan.”
Maybe we should stop defending them then. We just gave them 8 billion dollars recently for defense and now they want to give us an inferior product.
 
Let me get this straight. The chips will be made here and then shipped back to China for assembly. And that’s more cost effective?

Or is this all political theatre?
Wait until you look up pears.

Pears are harvested in south america (I think chile), then shipped to vietnam for packaging, then sent to the USA for selling. Horrible horrible waste. Globalism is a gigantic mistake.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.