After two weeks with the 2018 MacBook Pro, here's what I love and hate about it (coming from a 2018 MacBook Air). I'm interested to hear if you agree or disagree with these thoughts.
What I Love:
What I Hate:
What I Want:
I don't think this wish list is entirely unrealistic but I doubt Apple will deliver on the last item given it has doubled down on the touch bar with the new base MacBook Pro / former MacBook Escape.
What I Love:
- Screen quality, brightness, and color accuracy
- Sound quality
- Speed
- Touch ID
What I Hate:
- Touch Bar: The touch bar is a gimmick, pure and simple. It does not make sense for touch typists as you need to look down to see what you're tapping on versus feeling the F keys on a physical keyboard. Even with the expanded touch strip setting enabled, the touch bar is not fluid to engage with. I can't think of any real benefit that the touch bar provides outside of a few app-specific features but, even in those cases, I think it takes more time to look down and see what the touch bar options are versus using your cursor.
- Keyboard ("dislike", not "hate"): I no longer hate the new butterfly keyboard like I did when I first owned a 2016 MacBook Pro but I certainly don't love it. The 2018 design, however, is nicer than the 2016 and 2017 designs. I'm sure most can't tell the difference but having owned and sold models from 2016 and 2017, I do prefer the 2018 design over the first two attempts. I had plenty of reliability issues with the first two years, but did not have those issues with the 2018 MacBook Air keyboard. All of that said, I would welcome a scissor switch keyboard with more travel. We need something much better than what Apple has delivered.
What I Want:
I don't think this wish list is entirely unrealistic but I doubt Apple will deliver on the last item given it has doubled down on the touch bar with the new base MacBook Pro / former MacBook Escape.
- Scissor switch keyboard with more travel: I want to absolutely love an Apple keyboard like I do with the Lenovo X1 Carbon design. Why can't Apple deliver here? Is it their obsession with thinness and form over function?
- iPhone X-style no bezeled screen: Screen bezels are another point where Apple is lagging behind the competitors. It would be nice if our laptops felt as modern as our smartphones.
- Face ID over Touch ID: Touch ID is great but, no doubt, face ID would be a massive improvement.
- All physical, no touch bar keyboard: I doubt Apple will retreat on the touch bar. In fact, I think they'll only expand the touchable area below the screen. It's sad to see that Apple isn't listening to its consumers in this regard. I think the overwhelming majority of customers either hate the touch bar or don't see the appeal. I don't know anyone who absolutely loves it.