Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
We've hoping for external GPUs for so long now; I remember when Thunderbolt first came out, that was one of the ideas MR readers were really excited about. A thin, light laptop with great battery life for portability - then just plug in an external GPU if you want to do high end gaming. Shame it never really materialised.

I really hope Apple are considering this. They wouldn't even have to really do any work. Just release an SDK to allow this functionality on OS X and 3rd party graphics manufacturers can do the hard part of releasing the hardware. I know it would be massively popular.
 
Pretty neat. It reminds me of the Alienware graphics amplifier as an external device for boosting performance.

I can see how this would be quite useful for many people.
 
There are a number of products and solutions out there that already do this. However, they are extortionately expensive - and require a bit of hacking to get working.

I've never really understood why external thunderbolt enclosures are SO expensive. It's basically a box with a power supply and a thunderbolt controller card inside. The majority of them are not big enough to fit a full length/size graphics card, and also often don't have a power supply capable of driving the heavy power requirements of some of the beefiest graphics cards.

This is a welcome development though - and I hope it succeeds. I trust that the startup company will stand behind their product with full support, and keep maintaining the graphics card drivers, for a seamless user experience. I'm not quite sure how this will be achieved in practice though, as it seems Apple have made things difficult for the existing solutions to work. (Eg - it seems not possible to have an external GPU to power the built-in laptop display in OSX, it will only work with an external display on MacOS). On the demos I've seen, it requires a user to boot into Windows to get the external GPU to drive the built-in laptop display. It's not really a huge issue though, as I imagine the target audience for these type of devices will want to boot into Windows for some of the latest gaming titles, or be using an external display anyway.

I was considering building one of these myself with my son (who is an Avid gamer) but when I looked into the cost of such a unit (with existing components) it looked prohibitive. It would be cheaper to build a Hackintosh or a custom-build PC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mw360
The enclosure seems quite small for a full size card. I wonder if they use MXM modules?

Really? You're marketing to the Apple crowd with money and doing all this work on a external box, cabling, power and what have you and putting in a 950 series nvidia card? Wow. 1060 in the very least.

OS X has no Pascal drivers yet so an enclosure with a 1060 would be an expensive paperweight at this point.
 
Really? You're marketing to the Apple crowd with money and doing all this work on a external box, cabling, power and what have you and putting in a 950 series nvidia card? Wow. 1060 in the very least.

950 or 970. Gives them an easy differentiator between the models. One is below Oculus spec and one above. Nice, clear and Apple-like up-selling.
 
24-hours after the product ships its first unit, Apple announces it is abandoning the obsolete and embarrassingly outdated Thunderbolt support in all of their computer devices and operating systems. Announcing the new Apple interface "iScream", which eventually becomes affectionately known as "rush hour".

Their new marketing slogan "we know you're all in a hurry, but it's important to enjoy some idle time in the queue."
 
Average choice of GPUs. Asus are putting real versions of the GTX 1060, 1070 and 1080 in their laptops and others will soon follow. They're only lower clock speeds from the desktop versions.

Thunderbolt 3 should support 1080 and better high performance GPUs. I guess that explains the poorer choice in cards, TB2 probably can't utilise a 1080 to its maximum potential. But I'm only guessing on that.

Also, none of those cards available are any good for 4K or VR so that picture of the guy wearing the headset is kind of misleading.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rdav
I wonder if apple even looked at the new nvidia pascal gpu's? As the mobiles are almost at desktop level speeds! Which would make the macbooks again top of the market. Especially with the new i7's. Finally we would have CUDA on mac..
 
  • Like
Reactions: rdav
Certainly an easy way to modernize a 2013 Mac Pro a little, since Apple won't!

A little surprised Apple hasn't gotten on the external GPU train since they're so involved with and invested in Thunderbolt. I know they don't like selling "upgrades" other than a new machine, but they could sell a ton of these even to new buyers, Macbook Pro, Mac Pro, iMac - extra radio buttons in the online store for how many external GTX 1080 Thunderbolt 3 boxes you want to add 😉
 
  • Like
Reactions: rdav
Really? You're marketing to the Apple crowd with money and doing all this work on a external box, cabling, power and what have you and putting in a 950 series nvidia card? Wow. 1060 in the very least.
Guess you didn't read the article, Nvidia 10 series card was mentioned
[doublepost=1472036493][/doublepost]
I wonder if apple even looked at the new nvidia pascal gpu's? As the mobiles are almost at desktop level speeds! Which would make the macbooks again top of the market. Especially with the new i7's. Finally we would have CUDA on mac..
Well I just hope Apple would release the new MacBook Pros with Pascal GPUs, and in 13"/14" and 15"/16" variants, that'll make it a easy sell
 
TB1/TB2 doesn't really support eGPU 100% due to some issues for GFX cards, you have to jump through hoops abit to get it to work somewhat. TB3 added official support for eGPU.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rdav and Ezlivin
This is a welcome development though - and I hope it succeeds. I trust that the startup company will stand behind their product with full support, and keep maintaining the graphics card drivers, for a seamless user experience. I'm not quite sure how this will be achieved in practice though, as it seems Apple have made things difficult for the existing solutions to work. (Eg - it seems not possible to have an external GPU to power the built-in laptop display in OSX, it will only work with an external display on MacOS).

nvidia themselves supply the driver, they have a "web driver" on their website that supports kepler and maxwell cards. Been used by many a mac pro owner, and hackintosher, to allow more modern nvidia gpu's on OSX with great success. Unfortunetly no support for Pascal yet, hence no 1060/1070/etc support. Traditionally there has been a decent (6 month plus) delay between a new architecture coming out and nvidia supporting it on macOS. I'm hoping once sierra is out properly and their sierra drivers are out of beta that Pascal support will be added, can only hope!

I was considering building one of these myself with my son (who is an Avid gamer) but when I looked into the cost of such a unit (with existing components) it looked prohibitive. It would be cheaper to build a Hackintosh or a custom-build PC.

Yeh with the right hardware, you can get a very capable/compatible hackintosh and pc gaming combination that works out really well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: obiwan
I assume these dudes are running Bootcamp. VR software for macOS just doesn't exists. Gaming on macOS? Come on? Seems useful though but a little misleading, No?

I think the idea is to encourage future support for macOS in these sectors.
 
For all of you complaining about the choice of GPU: There is no GTX 1000 series driver support in macOS. These guys can't change that. It's why they are stuck with 900 series.

I assume these dudes are running Bootcamp. VR software for macOS just doesn't exists. Gaming on macOS? Come on? Seems useful though but a little misleading, No?

I think the idea is to encourage future support for macOS in these sectors.

www.vrdesktop.com
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.