There have been many inquiries with respect to Thunderbolt enclosures, and I've had my own questions. I finally compiled some data that others may find interesting and/or useful.
I was hoping to find a solution to house 4 drives -- 2 SSDs in RAID0 + another SSD + a fourth 3.5" drive for back-ups/archive. Ideally, it would be small, quiet, fast and inexpensive.
I measured the drive speed using BlackMagic Disk Speed Test with two Samsung 840 EVO 1TB drives in a RAID0 (AppleRAID/software) configuration. I also measured the noise from each unit as measured in dBA above the room's background noise. Each enclosure was 0.8m horizontal from my body and 0.2m below my ear.
The test system was a late 2013 iMac 27" core i7 (3.5).
For reference:
* The Sonnet Tempo Pro SSD card run inside my early 2008 Mac Pro (x16 slot) tested at 943MB/s read and 850MB/s write.
* The iMac's internal PCIe SSD (512) tested at 719MB/s read and 713MB/s write.
1: Sonnet Echo Express III-D with Sonnet Tempo Pro SSD PCI card {MSRP = $1260}
Read: 801 MB/s; Write 655 MB/s; +4dBA with both fans running, +1dBA with one fan.
Note: The Thunderbolt2 upgrade just became available. The tests were run with the TB1 card.
2: Promise Pegasus2 R4 diskless Thunderbolt2 {MSRP = $700}
Read: 823; Write 494; +3dBA
3: OWC Mercury Elite Pro Dual with both TB1 and USB3 connections {MSRP = $300}
TB Read: 381; Write 324; +3dBA
USB3 Read: 420; Write 338; +3dBA
Note: The fan on this unit is small and runs at a higher rate. I find the fan noise on this unit more objectionable than either that of the Pegasus2 or the Sonnet.
The Sonnet enclosure was far and away the fastest, but it is also the most expensive. I don't love the form factor. It isn't designed for 3.5" drives and if I want to add more drives I can do so...but I must buy additional cards. It has a lock mechanism for the TB cable. I thought it would be unnecessary but realized in this comparison that when I rotate my iMac a light tug on the iMac end of the cable sometimes resulted in disconnecting the cable from the other enclosures.
The Pegasus2 allows one to use 4 drives. I was hoping to love it but was a bit disappointed in the performance. I'd like to think that perhaps some of the lower performance was due to the lack of TB2 on the iMac, but a 2-drive RAID0 is under the TB1 bandwidth limit, and clearly the Sonnet enclosure can squeeze more out of the drives with TB1. It can handle 2.5 and 3.5" drives.
I like the size and price of the OWC enclosure, and the fact that it can use USB has some appeal. Unfortunately, the TB performance was quite disappointing -- slower than USB3? It is not upgradeable to TB2. The small form factor is great, but one must use an external power supply, which takes away from the form factor.
Hope this helps someone. I'm not quite sure what I will do but after this test I'm leaning toward the Sonnet setup. It is substantially more expensive than other options, but now that it is here...
----------
One additional point regarding sleep & wake:
1: Sleep is immediate & wake takes a second or two with the Sonnet but both work as expected. The Enclosure does power down when the Mac is asleep.
2: The Pegasus2 does sleep and wake (& power down), but it takes about 20 seconds or so before the drive(s) is recognized by the OS. This is a noticeable lag upon wake from sleep.
3: The OWC enclosure allows immediate sleep & wake (much better than the other two) but does not power down during sleep.
I was hoping to find a solution to house 4 drives -- 2 SSDs in RAID0 + another SSD + a fourth 3.5" drive for back-ups/archive. Ideally, it would be small, quiet, fast and inexpensive.
I measured the drive speed using BlackMagic Disk Speed Test with two Samsung 840 EVO 1TB drives in a RAID0 (AppleRAID/software) configuration. I also measured the noise from each unit as measured in dBA above the room's background noise. Each enclosure was 0.8m horizontal from my body and 0.2m below my ear.
The test system was a late 2013 iMac 27" core i7 (3.5).
For reference:
* The Sonnet Tempo Pro SSD card run inside my early 2008 Mac Pro (x16 slot) tested at 943MB/s read and 850MB/s write.
* The iMac's internal PCIe SSD (512) tested at 719MB/s read and 713MB/s write.
1: Sonnet Echo Express III-D with Sonnet Tempo Pro SSD PCI card {MSRP = $1260}
Read: 801 MB/s; Write 655 MB/s; +4dBA with both fans running, +1dBA with one fan.
Note: The Thunderbolt2 upgrade just became available. The tests were run with the TB1 card.
2: Promise Pegasus2 R4 diskless Thunderbolt2 {MSRP = $700}
Read: 823; Write 494; +3dBA
3: OWC Mercury Elite Pro Dual with both TB1 and USB3 connections {MSRP = $300}
TB Read: 381; Write 324; +3dBA
USB3 Read: 420; Write 338; +3dBA
Note: The fan on this unit is small and runs at a higher rate. I find the fan noise on this unit more objectionable than either that of the Pegasus2 or the Sonnet.
The Sonnet enclosure was far and away the fastest, but it is also the most expensive. I don't love the form factor. It isn't designed for 3.5" drives and if I want to add more drives I can do so...but I must buy additional cards. It has a lock mechanism for the TB cable. I thought it would be unnecessary but realized in this comparison that when I rotate my iMac a light tug on the iMac end of the cable sometimes resulted in disconnecting the cable from the other enclosures.
The Pegasus2 allows one to use 4 drives. I was hoping to love it but was a bit disappointed in the performance. I'd like to think that perhaps some of the lower performance was due to the lack of TB2 on the iMac, but a 2-drive RAID0 is under the TB1 bandwidth limit, and clearly the Sonnet enclosure can squeeze more out of the drives with TB1. It can handle 2.5 and 3.5" drives.
I like the size and price of the OWC enclosure, and the fact that it can use USB has some appeal. Unfortunately, the TB performance was quite disappointing -- slower than USB3? It is not upgradeable to TB2. The small form factor is great, but one must use an external power supply, which takes away from the form factor.
Hope this helps someone. I'm not quite sure what I will do but after this test I'm leaning toward the Sonnet setup. It is substantially more expensive than other options, but now that it is here...
----------
One additional point regarding sleep & wake:
1: Sleep is immediate & wake takes a second or two with the Sonnet but both work as expected. The Enclosure does power down when the Mac is asleep.
2: The Pegasus2 does sleep and wake (& power down), but it takes about 20 seconds or so before the drive(s) is recognized by the OS. This is a noticeable lag upon wake from sleep.
3: The OWC enclosure allows immediate sleep & wake (much better than the other two) but does not power down during sleep.
Last edited: