Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Are you saying they didn't? Source?
I’m dying laughing. That’s not how it works. Logic doesn’t let you make an unsupported suggestion, then demand proof that it isn’t true, and then use the absence of proof as evidence that it is true. LMAO! That’s how the moon got to be made of green cheese before the 1960s. But wait, speaking of that, here’s another one for you, my child: the moon landings were faked!! Can’t disprove it?? Then I’m right!! LMMFAO!!!


Edit: The more people disagree with the above, the more disappointed I become over the state of critical thinking today.
 
Last edited:
  • Disagree
Reactions: iStorm and LeeW
Apple's timing is surely questionable, I don't see any reason why this couldn't have been implemented in let's say iOS 10. In developer circles this hasn't been exactly a secret, that some apps need to access your clipboard.

It’s not so much whether the app in question needs to access your clipboard or not, but whether the user is aware that said app is in fact doing so.

For example, the iOS 13 beta showed that the YouTube app had Bluetooth active. This was conspicuously removed by the time iOS 13 was officially released to the masses. Definitely suspicious, but better late than never.

Clipboard disclosures don’t stop anything; they just inform you of what’s happening.

If it’s what you expect (as might be the case with 1Password) and you’re fine with it, great. Life goes on as per normal. If it’s unexpected and you think something illicit is going on in the background, you can then decide to stop using the app.

It’s really about giving the user more insight to empower them to make more informed decisions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DCIFRTHS
Typical Chinese stealing DNA. Comes down from top. Keep stealing until get caught.
 
Next time please share the working video. Thank you.
It’s not about the video, it’s a reddit thread. If you’re just looking for a headline, this should do it for you:

It’s referencing the same reddit thread.
 
It’s not about the video, it’s a reddit thread. If you’re just looking for a headline, this should do it for you:

It’s referencing the same reddit thread.

A data mining machine, masquerading as a social network, indeed.
 
One question I have is why do apps have access to the clipboard AT ALL?

Shouldn't the clipboard only be used when you PASTE something? It seems absurd that there'd be an API for an app to grab the clipboard contents without permission, and yet apparently it's been the case all along.
I think that's a reasonable request. The only reason I could see for constant access is for apps like Deliveries that could then check the clipboard for tracking numbers, but that should be protected by an iOS system prompt like any other form of data. It's actually way too easy to access the clipboard in iOS (literally a one-liner).
 
Theres a dating app Grindr that does the same thing. I stopped using it, the only way I knew it was pasting my data was it would say pasting data from clipboard for 27" iMac Pro... or pasting from iPad Pro 11"... I guess I outed myself.. with this one.. but this security feature will expose that app for the evil that it is and people will stop using those apps.. doubt it as people still sell their soul for free email COUGH COUGH GMAIL...

Yeah, it's why I stopped using Grindr awhile ago. I'm just not comfortable knowing that my data is being sent to the CCP. I really wish there was more awareness within the gay community. Like TikTok, it's unfortunate that it's so popular.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Osxguy
And no, the only option is not 90 seconds. The default option is. You can click on that 90, and edit it to whatever you are comfortable with.
You can't do that on the iOS version. That option is only available on the macOS version and we're talking about an iOS feature on this thread.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macintoshmac
Oh. You must have missed when China infiltrated our the Department of Energy, along with a handful of other government entities, along with 1 in 5 major US companies, like Tesla and Apple. It's as if, you think, there is no logical basis to give this criticism compared to american companies.

We are in a espionage war with China

Nobody cares about your war. The world is not only the US.
I agree some comments are indeed on racist side. as they scrutinise Tiktok whereas judge some other US based apps favourably.
 
Nothing new for the Chinese. I don’t who would ever use this app. I believe it needs to be banned in the USA.
[automerge]1593174087[/automerge]
before everyone dog piles on TikTok and the "Chinese" apps... there are several other offenders

maybe, but none have the Depth and breathe of intellectual property theft of the Chinese.
 
Unfortunately no. Most of the time I just copied passwords from Notes. Bank account number as well. Sometimes many times a day. I’m using iCloud Key Chain for some but not all my password.
I don’t think normal users use 1Password.
Keeping your passwords on Notes is a really bad idea. I highly recommend a password manager if you're worried about keeping yourself safe online.
 
  • Like
Reactions: icanhazmac
A data mining machine, masquerading as a social network, indeed.
Yup and I find that one commenter’s theory interesting; that it could potentially be used to gather discriminating information about you, to possibly blackmail you years/decades from now should you make it into a position of power, like politician or CEO.

It’s clever, playing the long game. Wouldn’t put that past the Chinese.
 
I'm not suggesting that at all. I'm suggesting that it's very easy for xenophobia to ooze onto the surface when all your friends are from one single ethnic group. 75% is an astonishing percentage in a country that claims to be the "melting pot". There are fewer minorities in Britain (where 81.9% of the population are whites) but over there only 33% of the whites don't have any non-white friends. In the US, you pretty much have to make a conscious effort not to have any non-white friends if you're middle class, don't work from home and live in an urban area on either coast. It's 75% in pretty much the most diverse country humanity has ever known.
Thank you for the clarification. I'm not trying to claim that this isn't a finding that reflects xenophobia in some ways, but I'd like to point out that it's a fallacy to blame this entirely on the individuals with no non-white friends. I just don't believe that is a helpful perspective. What this number reflects is a highly ethnically segregated infrastructure (A), a very prominent cultural gradient between the ethnic groups (B) and an extreme conflation of class and ethnic groups (C). All these things are partially due to active racism and partially due to inherited structures that have historically grown. All these problems work together. A white person, growing up in a wealthy white suburb will mostly play with white kids, because (A). He will likely go to a good private school, where because of (C), by far most kids will also be white. Even if there are a few black kids around, because of (B) the chances of common interests or mutual understanding are low. Calling latter xenophobia is a little unfair as we don't usually call this tendency to prefer friends with shared experiences xenophobia.

I don't want to say these things are okay, they are not. I believe however that we need to change the language we use to talk about these things from a moralistic-authoritarian one to a more empathetic one, and empathetic means that we don't just try to understand the supposed victims, but also the supposed perpetrators. Just because one group appears to benefit from certain circumstances, doesn't mean that they are therefore personally, individually responsible for them. If in a situation like this, people don't work together, but instead antagonize each other, then we are very likely to create more problems than we solve.
 
One question I have is why do apps have access to the clipboard AT ALL?

Shouldn't the clipboard only be used when you PASTE something? It seems absurd that there'd be an API for an app to grab the clipboard contents without permission, and yet apparently it's been the case all along.

There is a limited usability argument, e.g. a browser pre-loading the URL currently stored in the clipboard, but the sheer number of apps snooping on the clipboard data is abhorrent. And even if there is a usability advantage, which developers would you really trust to use this data responsibly besides Safari/Apple?
 
AFAIK almost every Chinese app does that, Weibo, WeChat, TikTok, Taobao... It's really great iOS has all those features.

On the other hand, Android users in China have to bear all the privacy issues all the time. Some apps even ask for permission to monitor user's phone call and texts. What if someone chooses not to give those apps the permissions? THEY STOP WORKING AND QUIT! That's insane!

If you’re living in China, you have no expectation of privacy. It doesn’t matter what device or OS you are on. I would argue that Android vs iOS being spied on is actually the least of your privacy problems in that country.
 
Thank you for the clarification. I'm not trying to claim that this isn't a finding that reflects xenophobia in some ways, but I'd like to point out that it's a fallacy to blame this entirely on the individuals with no non-white friends. I just don't believe that is a helpful perspective. What this number reflects is a highly ethnically segregated infrastructure (A), a very prominent cultural gradient between the ethnic groups (B) and an extreme conflation of class and ethnic groups (C). All these things are partially due to active racism and partially due to inherited structures that have historically grown. All these problems work together. A white person, growing up in a wealthy white suburb will mostly play with white kids, because (A). He will likely go to a good private school, where because of (C), by far most kids will also be white. Even if there are a few black kids around, because of (B) the chances of common interests or mutual understanding are low. Calling latter xenophobia is a little unfair as we don't usually call this tendency to prefer friends with shared experiences xenophobia.

I don't want to say these things are okay, they are not. I believe however that we need to change the language we use to talk about these things from a moralistic-authoritarian one to a more empathetic one, and empathetic means that we don't just try to understand the supposed victims, but also the supposed perpetrators. Just because one group appears to benefit from certain circumstances, doesn't mean that they are therefore personally, individually responsible for them. If in a situation like this, people don't work together, but instead antagonize each other, then we are very likely to create more problems than we solve.
I thoroughly enjoy reading your reply and your points are well taken. That being said, I don't think I was being "moralistic-authoritarian" in any of the posts I wrote. I was merely making an observation by citing a statistic of which I don't think there is any serious doubt about the fact that people who only hang around others of the same ethnic group tend to have more xenophobic tendencies. It could be, like you pointed out, that the 75% is systemic and individuals have little control over it. But could there also be an individual factor at play? I don't know. That's why I took great care in not calling names or assigning labels (xenophobic tendencies vs xenophobia). I was only trying to point out a possible correlation.

It does seem strange that you're so eager to defend and, I'd even go as far as saying, justify the status quo. An individual does have some agency in organizing their own lives, don't they? Whether it be choosing the career they want to pursue, the neighbourhood they want to live in and more importantly, the kinds of people they want to hang out with. Assigning so much blame to history and "the system" strikes me as more like a cop-out than a call for change.

Again, it's not my intention to antagonize and I wholeheartedly support your call for working together. I leave you with this article, which I think is very apropos to what we're discussing.
 
Thanks for your input!

I was seeing the same results as you. I was curious if the poster was aware of settings I wasn’t seeing.

As far as the 90 secs option, see my pic below. I am unable to change it. If you don’t mind me asking, do you have a subscription or a standalone version. I have the standalone version on my Mac, and the Pro version on my iPhone.

View attachment 927904

This is my mistake, I pointed the ability on macOS. We can’t change the time on iOS. However, I wonder if changing the setting on macOS reflects the change on iOS as well?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DCIFRTHS
Exactly why I stay with Apple. Privacy is something they truly care about; to their core.

But if Apple vets these apps and they've had IOS14 tested they should have already noticed this issue. So the bigger question is why did Apple let this happen and waited for a third party developer to ring the alarms?!
 
True dat. And given the Americans are probably one of the best at it they won’t get caught very often.
Just look at who controls hardware design or manufacturing and you have the two superpowers with the most field advantage to spy on others.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.