While the iPad surely wins in its simplicity and battery life; and the Apple Pencil has to be the best digital writing utensil on the planet - for the average student spending $1000 on a single device, they would much rather have the full functionality of a standard computer as their only machine. I can only imagine for Engineering-centric universities like mine this is even worse because of all the special windows software we have to use.
...
I was skeptical of Surface at first, but I enjoy mine.
If MS could streamline the windows experience to be more ipad like--it would reaally help. I hate all the weird sleep/wake issues, intrusive updates and so many little issues--like not being able to play a podcast with the screen off. I really like windows 10--as i have customized it. But if you don't know how to optimize it, I can see why people get discouraged. I see MS pushing more cortana and 3d, and I just wonder wtf? Windows is so close--just refine the experience. And--not to be disagreeable-apple pencil is fine but massively overhyped