To ATV or not to ATV

geoffpalmeruk

macrumors regular
Original poster
Nov 8, 2013
134
2
Exeter, Devon
That is my question....

In my house i currently have an old Mac mini G4 running Leopard server connected to airport express via ethernet which in turn talks to my Virgin router and my apple TV3 connected via wifi to the router and then HDMI to the TV (non smart 42 inch plasma)

I have been thinking of ways to reduce this to just one or 2 devices.

All my content is on a 1tb 2.5 inch HDD.

I was thinking of using a roku 3 and connecting my hdd via usb into it?
Or get a raspberry pi and usb content?

Are there any other recommendations? ideally i would like to pay as little as possible as i have a very small budget (under £100)

and i don't really want to go the NAS route.

My main requirements are:

Quiet (this is a must)
Low energy (less than Mac Mini, Apple TV and Airport Express combined)
Direct attachment for usb hdd (don't want buffering over the wifi)
Ethernet port would be nice.
As few devices as possible (hide it behind TV so wife doesn't see!)

Thanks in avdvance.
 

geoffpalmeruk

macrumors regular
Original poster
Nov 8, 2013
134
2
Exeter, Devon
see whilst i like the atv i am getting frustrated with the buffering issues and that i'm using bits of kit to do one job. As my server is on constantly it does use power and i know that there are alternatives out there that would be better suited.

Has anyone seen the cubox or other similar devices?

i just want the cheapest - lowest power solution and i don't think im doing it right...
 

Uofmtiger

macrumors 68020
Dec 11, 2010
2,041
741
Memphis
I believe Western Digital makes something like this, too. I have never used the USB feature on my Roku, but I would definitely try to research how these players handle USB (GUI) and how fast they load libraries if I was going this route.

Personally, I would try home plug (power line Ethernet) to get around the wifi issue, but that wouldn't solve your energy issue (unless you had a NAS or computer that woke up only when needed).
 

geoffpalmeruk

macrumors regular
Original poster
Nov 8, 2013
134
2
Exeter, Devon
Thnkas for the feedback. I htink i'll have a look into the WD solution and see if there is anywhere with the roku i can test. :)

If only the ATV had a usb port i could use :(
 

0970373

Suspended
Mar 15, 2008
2,732
1,406
That is my question....

In my house i currently have an old Mac mini G4 running Leopard server connected to airport express via ethernet which in turn talks to my Virgin router and my apple TV3 connected via wifi to the router and then HDMI to the TV (non smart 42 inch plasma)

I have been thinking of ways to reduce this to just one or 2 devices.

All my content is on a 1tb 2.5 inch HDD.

I was thinking of using a roku 3 and connecting my hdd via usb into it?
Or get a raspberry pi and usb content?

Are there any other recommendations? ideally i would like to pay as little as possible as i have a very small budget (under £100)

and i don't really want to go the NAS route.

My main requirements are:

Quiet (this is a must)
Low energy (less than Mac Mini, Apple TV and Airport Express combined)
Direct attachment for usb hdd (don't want buffering over the wifi)
Ethernet port would be nice.
As few devices as possible (hide it behind TV so wife doesn't see!)

Thanks in avdvance.
What about installing Plex on the Mac Mini server w/ the HDD attached to that and getting a Roku? The new Roku stick is $50 and the Roku 3 has a USB & Ethernet port if you wanted to use it that way.
 

geoffpalmeruk

macrumors regular
Original poster
Nov 8, 2013
134
2
Exeter, Devon
What about installing Plex on the Mac Mini server w/ the HDD attached to that and getting a Roku? The new Roku stick is $50 and the Roku 3 has a USB & Ethernet port if you wanted to use it that way.
Thanks for the reply.

the main reason of doing this was to eliminate as much as possible and reduce power usage.

"I have been thinking of ways to reduce this to just one or 2 devices."
"Low energy (less than Mac Mini, Apple TV and Airport Express combined)"

Thus simply changing the ATV for a roku and keep the mini does not fix this. I have decided to go ahead and buy a Raspberry Pi and will move all my content onto a Directly attached 2.5 inch USB HDD.

Then i can remove the Mac Mini, Airport Express and ATV3 and my 3.5inch HDD.

and all for the cost of £35 :)

Thanks for the advice though.
 

blanka

macrumors 68000
Jul 30, 2012
1,549
3
Great choice. RaspBMC is excellent and easy to control with your iPhone. And only running on like 5 watt.