Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

SeanEE89

macrumors regular
Original poster
Feb 15, 2008
116
0
VA, United States
I was wondering if Apple is going to come out with a solution to enable people to actually burn and play Blu-Ray discs? I just bought a new MacBook this past thursday and I was curious.
 
That's a great question...

I was wondering if Apple is going to come out with a solution to enable people to actually burn and play Blu-Ray discs? I just bought a new MacBook this past thursday and I was curious.

since my MBA and my BlackBook 2.4 Penryn won't even recognize the Blu-Ray Disc and both computers "spat" the disc out in a matter of seconds! :confused::(
 
Duff-Man says...Perhaps an obvious answer, but I suspect that Apple will provide built-in Blu-Ray support when they start shipping their computers with Blu-Ray drives...oh yeah!
 
i guess that toast only will work with external optical drives, cuz apple still didn't release the blue ray option yet!!!, thats why they r available with toast :p
 
i guess that toast only will work with external optical drives, cuz apple still didn't release the blue ray option yet!!!, thats why they r available with toast :p

Well, you can get internal ones fitted. Roxio are just getting ready for a future (almost) certainty.
 
is there a way I could play Blu-Ray Movies with my MacBook? I know they can support external monitors up to 1900 X 1200 which is adequate enough for 1080p.
 
since my MBA and my BlackBook 2.4 Penryn won't even recognize the Blu-Ray Disc and both computers "spat" the disc out in a matter of seconds! :confused::(

is there a way I could play Blu-Ray Movies with my MacBook? I know they can support external monitors up to 1900 X 1200 which is adequate enough for 1080p.

are spitting out the Blu-Ray Disc like it's "a bad sunflower seed!" :(:eek:

One, SFStateStudent, if I get this right... you are trying to play a blu-ray movie with a dvd drive? I know the discs may be the same size and may fit into a player, but that does not make them compatible. That's like trying to play a dvd with a VCR. Or, trying to play a dvd with your walkman. Your macbook will only be able to play a blu-ray movie with a blu-ray drive. Apple doesn't have them internal yet. You can buy external drives, but even then, you have to play the movie with windows because no mac apps support blu-ray playback yet (to my knowledge).

SeanEE89, read above. You can play High-Def material with your macbook, such as streaming movies online, buying digital copies, etc. But, you can't play from a blu-ray disc. Just like the macbook air can't even play a CD without the external superdrive, you won't be able to play blu-ray until you have a blu-ray drive in your computer or attached externally.

And, since you will undoubtedly ask this next, no one knows when macs will adopt blu-ray... if ever. Most likely it will be this summer, as intel's Montevina platform provides support for it, but who knows.
 
are spitting out the Blu-Ray Disc like it's "a bad sunflower seed!" :(:eek:

I just tried Transporter 2 and it spit out the Blu-Ray disc after trying to read it :confused:

Ok, how old are you two?

It's spitting it out because it's a CD/DVD drive. You're trying to put a blu-ray disc into it. They are not the same technology. blu-ray players are generally backwards compatible, that is to say a blu-ray player will play a DVD, but that does not work the other way around. Blu-ray discs are read with a different type of laser. DVD drives cannot read them anymore than your VCR can.

To be clear: Blu-ray IS NOT a high-def movie on a DVD. It is a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT TYPE OF DISC, and your DVD drive CANNOT read them.
 
yep, TEG...

1) You need a Blu-Ray Drive to view a Blu-Ray disc.

2) VLC plays Blu-Ray movies just fine.

TEG

I figured that puppy out, but I was trying to view a blu-ray disc on my BlackBook or my MBA by mini-DVI to S-Video or anything, but I'll just wait to get my new BD-ROM for $299. I've got the Samsung HD/Blu-Ray Disc Player (Dual) for about $450 v. $799, so I'm happy with the 40" Sony Bravia LCD 1080i thang!
:cool:
 
I figured that puppy out, but I was trying to view a blu-ray disc on my BlackBook or my MBA by mini-DVI to S-Video or anything, but I'll just wait to get my new BD-ROM for $299. I've got the Samsung HD/Blu-Ray Disc Player (Dual) for about $450 v. $799, so I'm happy with the 40" Sony Bravia LCD 1080i thang!
:cool:

Are you saying that you have a blu-ray player and that you were trying to use the screen of your macbook to play a movie on? Through the mini-dvi? For real? That port is an output, not an input.

And no need to dis on my "handle" just because you asked a dumb question.
 
I figured that puppy out, but I was trying to view a blu-ray disc on my BlackBook or my MBA by mini-DVI to S-Video or anything, but I'll just wait to get my new BD-ROM for $299. I've got the Samsung HD/Blu-Ray Disc Player (Dual) for about $450 v. $799, so I'm happy with the 40" Sony Bravia LCD 1080i thang!
:cool:

VLC can output to other displays other than than the built-in quite easily.

TEG
 
Oh my...

Are you saying that you have a blu-ray player and that you were trying to use the screen of your macbook to play a movie on? Through the mini-dvi? For real? That port is an output, not an input.

And no need to dis on my "handle" just because you asked a dumb question.

what does this little button do? "Ignore List" "P-O-O-F" Bye AROPEADOPE!
:eek::eek::cool:
 
I know the technology differences between DVDs, HD DVDs and Blu-Ray thank you very much. I was just taking a suggestion on the matter. I am going to guess there are no external blu-ray drives for the Mac. I have seen though that the Mac can access PC disc drives and play off of those does that mean if my PC had a Blu-Ray ROM I would be able to access and play off of that as well?
 
vlc and bd?

I saw TEG's comments and was crazy excited. I installed VLC but still have no idea how to get it to play bd. Tried google, did not find any answers (though I did not do an exhaustive search) I have LG GGC-H20L installed on Mac Pro 2008 model. VLC only has disc recognition for dvd/cd. Tried checking them all... does not see the disc. Tried opening via file, tried most folders and files got nothing. Any help, hints, or direction would be very, very, very appreciated. Do I need to copy to hard drive to get it to play?
 
Do I need to copy to hard drive to get it to play?

I don't have BD drive to check but pretty sure if you grab the BD equivalent of the first main VoB file directly off the disc and drop it on the VLC icon then the next file will be automatically picked up.

To change monitors just drag the window to the HD monitor.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.