Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


While Apple launched a bunch of new hardware this week, the biggest news was on the software side where a delay for some of the previously announced Apple Intelligence Siri features has led to scrutiny of Apple's actions and uneasiness among those at the company.

top-stories-2025-03-15.jpg
 
1. Apple really needs to focus on their existing lineup and put some muscle into Siri.
2. In re: iPhone 17 mockups, I am no designer, but I am of the opinion that the flash and sensor are incorrectly placed, and holding the phone in landscape mode for pics will cause problems. "You're holding it wrong" redux?
 
I can’t wait to see how this new Siri is going to work in my home. My kitchen has two new large HomePods that are paired. Then there is my 12 year old’s iPad, my wife’s iPad and sometimes my iPad sitting in the kitchen. In addition, my son’s iPhone and wife’s iPhone sit 10 feet down the hallway on a table. When we are in the kitchen and say “Siri”, we expect the HomePods to answer. But many times, if someone is using an iPad, their iPad tries to reply or turn its volume up or down and not the HomePod. And why in the h does Siri say “I’ll *speak* softer” when you ask her to turn the music volume down??? I see very troubled times ahead as they probably are re-writing this from the ground up (or at least need to!)
 
Why criticize apple for holding back when they realize they must have a buggy piece of software? Sure seems the trend has been release letting the consumer work out the kinks. This seems like a welcome attitude towards rolling out new features
 
I could personally care less about Apple Intelligence and hope that Apple quits treating it like it is THE major selling point for anything. The only thing I would like AI to do for me on my phone is to automatically prevent me from knowing someone sent me a SPAM text (politics or any marketing at all). I will be impressed with AI once SPAM of every sort is no longer an issue. AI is mainly Silicon Valley's (and other tech industries) latest snake oil in the search of the next big thing.
 
AI isn't the killer app for consumers that the tech media makes it out to be. Most buyers just don't care.

Apple can take their time if consumer surveys are to be believed.
Most people want innovative products. AI was only jumped on because innovation and tech advances have slowed in some ways which meant there hasn’t been a whole bunch of new to sell to consumers. A laptop from 2015 can do much of what an average Apple user needs to do today. The only struggle is maybe bloated websites but that’s another issue.

My only wish is maybe Apple was a bit more daring with some of its products. I’d love to see radical designs tried out for laptops and iPads in one of their products lines in that area.

I mean even the desktops need playing about with. Why can’t they dominant the micro PC market by releasing a Mac Micro. A credit card sized computer with M series chip, 16 GB RAM. Like the MeLe products.

That would be awesome.

Imagine Tim Cook taking out that product from his pocket, connecting it up to a single USB C type connector on a monitor. An entire desktop PC you can carry in your pocket. It would be the college students dream machine.
 
AI isn't the killer app for consumers that the tech media makes it out to be. Most buyers just don't care.

Apple can take their time if consumer surveys are to be believed.
I agree. Broken or unreliable is worse. We can access Gemini and OpenAI perplexity on Apple devices. What are we missing out on? Siri even offers or can be directed to ask chatgpt.

Photo editing and generation also available via other apps including Gemini.
 
Everybody is focusing on the wrong thing.

Siri sucking has nothing to do with AI and has everything to do with Siri stuck in 2012. It's that bad. Does Apple use their own products?
 
  • Like
Reactions: KeithBN
AI isn't the killer app for consumers that the tech media makes it out to be. Most buyers just don't care.

Apple can take their time if consumer surveys are to be believed.
That’s what Kodak said when Kyocera released the first camera phone in 1999.

Somewhere there’s a ‘bookstore’ you’ve never heard of that’s toying around with an idea.
 
I wonder what the fly on the wall heard in the meeting of the Board of Directors meeting discussing this AI issue?

The ages of many of them make me wonder if they stayed awake the whole time?

Are they aware enough to realize what a big deal this is that Apple went on national and international media to hype a non-existent product to sell model year 2024/2025 products, many of which were just a chip upgrade, using AI as the carrot?

How many law firms are looking to see how this incident could improve their cash flow?

I would suggest that Apple has sunk to higher than their knees in barn yard muck over this. There has been no comments from the top levels of management. Maybe they should get there heads out off the same muck and be honest with the millions of Apple customers who want to know the truth.

Saying they are years away from getting AI working would be a start and show some integrity and reality that their software teams were not up to the job despite the millions spent in that department.

Apple needs more than bean counters to run this technology company. It needs engineers of all types at the top to guide and kick back sides when needed and fire those not fired with enthusiasm.
 
I wonder what the fly on the wall heard in the meeting of the Board of Directors meeting discussing this AI issue?

The ages of many of them make me wonder if they stayed awake the whole time?

Are they aware enough to realize what a big deal this is that Apple went on national and international media to hype a non-existent product to sell model year 2024/2025 products, many of which were just a chip upgrade, using AI as the carrot?

How many law firms are looking to see how this incident could improve their cash flow?

I would suggest that Apple has sunk to higher than their knees in barn yard muck over this. There has been no comments from the top levels of management. Maybe they should get there heads out off the same muck and be honest with the millions of Apple customers who want to know the truth.

Saying they are years away from getting AI working would be a start and show some integrity and reality that their software teams were not up to the job despite the millions spent in that department.

Apple needs more than bean counters to run this technology company. It needs engineers of all types at the top to guide and kick back sides when needed and fire those not fired with enthusiasm.
It’s no accident that this announcement was made a week after the 2/25 board/shareholders meeting or it would have dominated the floor.
 
Why criticize apple for holding back when they realize they must have a buggy piece of software? Sure seems the trend has been release letting the consumer work out the kinks. This seems like a welcome attitude towards rolling out new features
The criticism stems from Apple heavily marketing the iPhone 16 around Apple Intelligence. If that hadn’t been the central selling point, the delay wouldn’t be nearly as much of an issue.
 
[…] Maybe they should get there heads out off the same muck and be honest with the millions of Apple customers who want to know the truth.

Saying they are years away from getting AI working would be a start and show some integrity and reality that their software teams were not up to the job despite the millions spent in that department.

[…]
You know Apple better than that. Would I like to know what went on behind the scenes? Sure. But I’m not going to be one of those types of critics on Macrumors. AI on phones right now, imo are parlor tricks. It’s going to take a while to see where this goes.
 
Why criticize apple for holding back when they realize they must have a buggy piece of software? Sure seems the trend has been release letting the consumer work out the kinks. This seems like a welcome attitude towards rolling out new features
The criticism isn’t of Apple for holding back when realising their software is buggy and massively feature-incomplete.

The criticism is of Apple for making grand announcements last year of features which were nothing more than vague ideas and concepts, claiming they were ready to release imminently, while knowing they were not even developed yet let alone debugged or ready.

And that criticism is wholly valid.

Let’s be realistic here.
It’s pretty obvious that the original plan was to release the full AI suite in iOS 19.
Which would have been pretty impressive - a fully featured, integrated, working AI built in at os-level.

Sadly, shareholders got fidgety with the OpenAI hype, and Apple directors panicked and told Apple to announce AI in iOS 18 even though it was nowhere near ready.

Which has resulted in this awful fiasco, and damaged Apple’s reputation, weakening confidence in the company.

A company which was hitherto well known for not announcing things until they were releasing them.

Except for AirPower and Apple Intelligence.

Let’s hope the executive floor take a good hard look at this whole debacle and learn from it.
I fear they won’t, however…
 
Most people want innovative products. AI was only jumped on because innovation and tech advances have slowed in some ways which meant there hasn’t been a whole bunch of new to sell to consumers. A laptop from 2015 can do much of what an average Apple user needs to do today. The only struggle is maybe bloated websites but that’s another issue.

My only wish is maybe Apple was a bit more daring with some of its products. I’d love to see radical designs tried out for laptops and iPads in one of their products lines in that area.

I mean even the desktops need playing about with. Why can’t they dominant the micro PC market by releasing a Mac Micro. A credit card sized computer with M series chip, 16 GB RAM. Like the MeLe products.

That would be awesome.

Imagine Tim Cook taking out that product from his pocket, connecting it up to a single USB C type connector on a monitor. An entire desktop PC you can carry in your pocket. It would be the college students dream machine.
iMac... you don't need to connect your computer on a.... what??
 
AI on phones right now, imo are parlor tricks. It’s going to take a while to see where this goes.
I largely agree, for non-chat applications. The issue is that Apple advertised something different, and for some reason thought they could deliver, and maybe still think they can deliver with just some additional delay.

There seems just too much delusion going on, from apparently not realizing over many years how bad Siri really is, to thinking that “spacial computing” with a heavy VR headset would catch on.
 
Last edited:
I find it interesting that one guy writes an article and people are thinking the sky is falling.
He’s most likely a great guy, but unless he’s working inside apple he’s another blogger with his own creative thinking, that may or may not have any relevance. Most reputable company's want the product they provide to be at its best, who rolls out something thats no going to work as advertised. Do it once and do it right. How can you miss a feature you’ve never had?
 
  • Like
Reactions: neotint
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.