Incase Slider all the way, I've used other ones and the Slider is definately the best... That's why it costs more. What makes it the best ( and perfect for you ) is that it has little rubber guard rails on the inside that keep the case from scratching or damaging your phone and they act as little air bags ( without the air ) if you drop it. I've gone through so many phones and just destroy them quickly, that's why I got this case, and even though I baby my phone and have never dropped it... I know that if I do it's safe... Get the Slider.