a testament to how bad our system of law is that the feature is no longer even used they are still fighting over.
What's even dumber is that a court had thrown out this award, declaring that the patent was invalid.
An appeals court later reinstated the award, saying that the other court used information that wasn't available to the jury in the original trial. (Prior art etc.) Therefore the ignorant jury's decision should stand.
So instead of justice based on more knowledge, you get a decision based solely on blindly following rules.
It might be legally correct, but it fails the common sense test.