Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
lacie drives are rubbish, had so many bad reports of these that I would never purchase one.

Those porsche drives get hot, but every external drive I own is LaCie and I whole heartedly recommend them. They are also all we use at work and in my family and touch wood, the only problems we've had is the usual hard-drive death after a few years of use.
 
Those porsche drives get hot, but every external drive I own is LaCie and I whole heartedly recommend them. They are also all we use at work and in my family and touch wood, the only problems we've had is the usual hard-drive death after a few years of use.


Me too, ours don't get that hot, we have four and my two are stacked and have been faultless, one at home too is superb. Mind you, all are Firewire.
 
lacie drives are rubbish, had so many bad reports of these that I would never purchase one.

I have always used Lacie and I've never heard any bad reports and will continue to buy them, 3 fellow students own differing portable versions all with no problems. Don't you just love anecdotal evidence?
 
There are plenty of horror stories with LaCie drives on this forum, including mine. They are noisier than most and LaCie never seems to design its drives with adequate cooling.

Pretty is not always better.
 
There are plenty of horror stories with LaCie drives on this forum, including mine. They are noisier than most and LaCie never seems to design its drives with adequate cooling.

Pretty is not always better.


If you chose your purchases on the evidence from this site, nobody would ever buy a Mac again :rolleyes:
 
Don't you just love anecdotal evidence?

My reports are from the university mac users email list which relates to about 300 people. Over the years there have been many problems with lacie drives (especially with their big discs). So I personally will never buy a lacie drive. ymmv
 
My reports are from the university mac users email list which relates to about 300 people. Over the years there have been many problems with lacie drives (especially with their big discs). So I personally will never buy a lacie drive. ymmv

Ditto
 
I've owned 3 Lacie's in my time - one went through several stages of breaking down (Firewire died, then the USB 2 weeks later, then the power supply), another's power supply died a week after purchase, and the third has been pretty solid, if a little hot.

I don't buy them any more, as my experience with them has not been that great.
 
4 LaCie drives here, from 160 - 500GB USB2.0/FW400/FW800.

Never had a problem with any of them. In fact, I use a FW800 drive as my iTunes library disk, and scratch disk. It is running about 6 - 8 hours a day, without spinning down.

I worked at a high spec'd film school, and the entire campus used LaCie HD's. No problems.

All of my friends, video artists, graphic professionals, digital media artists, musicians, all use LaCie drives with no problems.
 
Hard drive recommendations are very personal. I wouldn't wittingly buy another WD drive as I had 2 fail on me when they were less than 12 months old. The only disadvantage I can see for LaCie is that they don't manufacturer their own drives so you don't know what's inside.

But anyway - to the OP, get a firewire drive. If you get USB, you may not regret it now, but at some point you probably will!
 
My reports are from the university mac users email list which relates to about 300 people. Over the years there have been many problems with lacie drives (especially with their big discs). So I personally will never buy a lacie drive. ymmv

Still its only anecdotal evidence. Remember, we only complain when things go wrong on these boards. Like another poster said we would never buy anything if we listened to the people on these boards looking for advice about Mac's.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.