Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This probably has as much to do with nobody buying desktops across the board as Apples weaker offerings.

Desktops are dead - at home and in the office. Only you Americans can afford the luxury of a dedicated table/space for you computer. The rest of the world is now living buildings where space is at a premium.

The only "desktop" I'd ever buy again would be a pizza box shape that fits under the tv with a wireless display. This is the future. Desktops will become what we now call "workstations".

This is why you can bet your bunnies that we'll see 970 (or whatever) laptops sooner than later. Apple must stay on top in the laptop market.

a.
 
Re: Re: UK PowerBooks up, Desktops Down

Originally posted by visor
No wonder.
Desktops are noisy, comparatively slow and way overpriced.
Noone who doesn't really have to, would buy one now.
Hope they get a good replacement soon.

Power Mac:
$2,567.00
17-inch monitor
Dual 1.25GHz PowerPC G4
1MB L3 cache/processor
256MB DDR333 SDRAM
80GB Ultra ATA/100
SuperDrive
ATI Radeon 9700 Pro
64MB DDR video memory
FireWire 800
56K internal modem
Bluetooth
AirPort Extreme
AppleCare Protection Plan

PowerBook:
$3,648.00
17-inch TFT Display
1440x900 resolution
1GHz PowerPC G4
1MB L3 cache
512MB DDR333 SDRAM
60GB Ultra ATA/100
SuperDrive
NVIDIA GeForce4 440 Go
64MB DDR video memory
Gigabit Ethernet
FireWire 400
FireWire 800
AirPort Extreme built-in
Bluetooth built-in
DVI & S-Video out
AppleCare Protection Plan

The Power Mac has more bang for less buck. The only advantage of a PowerBook is you can take it with you.
 
Re: Re: Re: UK PowerBooks up, Desktops Down

Originally posted by Phil Of Mac
Power Mac:
$2,567.00


+ cheap desk 300 pounds (500USD?)
+ chair 200 pounds (350USD?)

gets closer and closer to that powerbook price.

AND, the desktop doesn't let you surf your way to sleep at night. Gotta have the powerbook ;)

a.
 
Originally posted by Dave_B
Their entry level desktop, the eMac, is very, very ugly and any-colour-so-long-as-its-white is never going to have the popular appeal that the bright and cheerful scheme of the original iMac enjoyed.

Well, I wouldn't have bought an old Imac as well. I used the ibook as entry level mac. A good opportunity to se if MacOSX was worth working with.

To sum it up - yes I like OSX, but why the hell does it feel like running on a 200mhz Pentium2?
 
Re: Re: Re: UK PowerBooks up, Desktops Down

Originally posted by Phil Of Mac
Power Mac:
$2,567.00
17-inch monitor
Dual 1.25GHz PowerPC G4
1MB L3 cache/processor
256MB DDR333 SDRAM
80GB Ultra ATA/100
SuperDrive
ATI Radeon 9700 Pro
64MB DDR video memory
FireWire 800
56K internal modem
Bluetooth
AirPort Extreme
AppleCare Protection Plan


The Power Mac has more bang for less buck. The only advantage of a PowerBook is you can take it with you.

You're right, that PowerMac would have more bang - but the price is somewhat different here.
I put the thing toghether in the German apple Store and came to an end price of 4004.32 Euro
That beeing about 4604 US$ at current exchange rate.
Almost double the price as in the States as it looks. Would you pay that?
 
Is it just me or did this forum turn into an argument between whether desktops or laptops are better?

Hello people, they're two completely different beasts. Last time I had expansion bays I seem to remember using them to the best of my advantage.

And I don't know that global real estate has become just so precious that no one has room for a desk. Especially as computers more and more replace all the things people used to use desks for.

I'm in a 1,200 square foot house with two adults and four children in it. We have two iMacs and two PCs.

I don't think the desktop is going to go away just so people can clear their computer in time for dinner :rolleyes:

And compression is not keeping up with bloat. Show me a laptop that can hold four HDs and eight ram slots and I'll show you a desktop that holds eight HDs and twelve RAM slots.

I love laptops and everything, but, come on, seriously people, don't start predicting the death of the desktop just yet.
 
Originally posted by mim
Desktops are dead - at home and in the office. Only you Americans can afford the luxury of a dedicated table/space for you computer. The rest of the world is now living buildings where space is at a premium.

What the heck are you talking about?:confused:

So you are the spokesman for the rest of the world? I don't think so!

All people I know never based their decision to buy a laptop vs. a desktop on dedicated table space they would have to provide. It's way more complex than that and Portability is reason number one. Also a lot of people have both, because a desktop provides much more expandibility and power than a laptop. It always depends on what you want to do.

I believe for most people the major reason to buy a laptop for private use is the comfort to bring it everywhere and to carry it around also at home. It is very convenient to be able to work anywhere in the house or appartement and being able to stay online through WLAN.

groovebuster
 
Originally posted by groovebuster
What the heck are you talking about?:confused:

So you are the spokesman for the rest of the world? I don't think so!

I'm talking about trends that are quite well reported and studied. I haven't looked at it for a while, but you might find some info on DEWG's web site. They plan people's office spaces. They're well... pretty bloody influential. As far as I know, they haven't designed an office that >doesn't< revolve around hot-desking in some fashion.

In their own office, everyone picks up a laptop on their way in, and finds a desk. And seeing as they advise (for space planning) most major corporations in the world...you could say this view is getting pretty well established. Lots of places still have fixed workstations - but this is changing very quickly. Most new offices (and yes - I've help design a few - even one in Berlin) acknowledge that these modes of working will become the norm.

And also being involved in a residential developments in a few cities across the world I can say that a space for a dedicated office/computer workstation or desk is >not< being offered. In terms of space it's too expensive and extravagent. Rather than pay the additional $2000-3000 >PER SQUARE METRE< for a study space (or even compact office shelving etc) more people are turning to laptops for their home.

So no - I'm not a the spokesman for the world - but I get out there enough to see what's going on. Try it sometime.

[edit: I'm not trying to say no-one will want desktops, just that most people will start to buy laptops as they become more powerful. These guys http://www4.gartner.com/pages/section.php.id.2034.s.8.jsp had a huge study on the growth of mobile computers. I don't have time to dig for it right noe, but it's there somewhere. I'm not trying to start an argument - I'm just saying what is actually happening. Like it or buy a desktop!]

cheers,
a.
 
Originally posted by amnesiac1984

Besides, I got the mid range powermac from the first load of MDD's and htat was a good deal, basically £1500 for a Dual 1 GHZ with a fat graphics card. GOod Enough for me. If I didn't want to put two extra Audio only hard disks inside my computer and fill it up with RAM and use too processors worth of audio units then I may possibly have considered getting a PowerBook.
I got the same powermac (now quietened with the PSU kit;) ). Got it for £1350 as it was an 'old-model'. Personally I don't care whether it's as fast as a 3GHz P4 as I don't want a P4 machine - I want a mac. It's faster than my old Athlon XP 1700, a lot nicer to use and quieter. How many people here who are moaning will be out buying these fabled pentium 4-kicking machines when they arrive? Or will they just start complaining how much they cost? Whining on about how lousy the mac desktops are doesn't exactly help Apple sell more macs does it? Some people may need the power of 3Ghz P4 machine - most don't. That's why the emac is a perfectly acceptable machine for the majority of people that buy PCs. The sort of people who think a faster processor makes the internet faster...:rolleyes:
Originally posted by Mim

+ cheap desk 300 pounds (500USD?)
+ chair 200 pounds (350USD?)

gets closer and closer to that powerbook price.
Wow...you shop at expensive furniture stores;)
 
Ok, I am a student, and can't afford a PB, so I will have to get a PM if I want a new computer...

And euhm, I guess everybody has a chair in their home, and has a desk, what are you complaining about, Mim. I myself need a desk, to study on, so I can put a PM under the desk, and above it the monitor... (I btw have a very big desk, on what I can put about 5 PM's, with monitors (don't have the money for that though)). And, for a computer desk, you pay, 50-100$, for a normall one, and a chair, I am sure you can grab it from any place, if you can't, put the desk next to your bed, and then go sit on your bed, and use the computer. Where is the problem???

Anyways, I think the PM sales will boost as soon as the PPC 970 gets released in PM's...
 
Originally posted by mim
In their own office, everyone picks up a laptop on their way in, and finds a desk. And seeing as they advise (for space planning) most major corporations in the world...you could say this view is getting pretty well established. Lots of places still have fixed workstations - but this is changing very quickly. Most new offices (and yes - I've help design a few - even one in Berlin) acknowledge that these modes of working will become the norm.

Since I am working with a lot of companies of different sizes I can't confirm that at all. They predict all that stuff since more than 10 years (teleworking and that kind of office you were referring to) and so far not a lot changed. I know companies that tried that stuff and went back to traditional working methods because it was almost impossible to work effectively that way.

In big companies they work with thin clients (administration staff) and workstations (developers and media staff) but still no laptops all across in sight. When you have to work at your desk anyway every day a workstation doesn't take more space than a laptop anyway. The PC goes under the table, an LCD and the keyboard use hardly more space than a laptop on the desk. And I can't think of almost any office desk that doesn't need a computer for daily tasks, so it has to be there anyway. Since the profiles of the users are stored on the server it is also no problem to switch desks with somebody else for a while. Laptops are only for the sales people who have to bring their stuff with them. Not any difference in small companies. I believe what I see and it is way different to what you want to sell/tell me. Nobody knows the norm of tomorrow just because there are some "innovative" (disputable anyway) exceptions. Norm means the majority is doing it and we are far from that for years. Maybe (and that's what I predict) it will never happen for the majority of companies and people.

Originally posted by mim
And also being involved in a residential developments in a few cities across the world I can say that a space for a dedicated office/computer workstation or desk is >not< being offered.

Of course not, because even a workstation is not taking much space today, it fits nicely under the table. Days are gone when computers had the size of a king size fridge. An LCD and a keyboard are not a lot bigger than a laptop.

Originally posted by mim
The only space you have to scar In terms of space it's too expensive and extravagent. Rather than pay the additional $2000-3000 >PER SQUARE METRE< for a study space (or even compact office shelving etc) more people are turning to laptops for their home.

How many companies have office space for $2000-3000 per m^2? You are kidding, right? Also an appartment doesn't cost that much when you are not so crazy to move to a yuppie quartier. And if you are able to pay that much per m^2, space for an extra computer desk for at home is the last concern you normally have...

Maybe you should start thinking about the real "norm" and not just the upper 10% of people or companies.

Originally posted by mim
So no - I'm not a the spokesman for the world - but I get out there enough to see what's going on. Try it sometime.

Look who's talking! :D

No offense dude, but it seems that I seem to get out there way more often than you do, regarding what you are writing. All those predictions about our working environment were totally wrong since 10 years. And it will probably stay like this for the next 10 years when I look at the predictions they do now...

Just open your eyes when you get out of your ivory tower and you'll see what the real norm is.

Let's talk about it in 10 years again. I'm curious if anything what was predicted today really will have happened then.

(I remember that when I was little they predicted colonies and mining on the moon in the year 2000 as well as cars that run with alternative energy. My travel agent still refuses to sell me a ticket to moon... weird, huh?)

Peace, :cool:

groovebuster
 
Originally posted by visor
Well, I wouldn't have bought an old Imac as well. I used the ibook as entry level mac. A good opportunity to se if MacOSX was worth working with.

To sum it up - yes I like OSX, but why the hell does it feel like running on a 200mhz Pentium2?

I believe that would be the anti-RSI protection software installed by default with OSX . Its not acutally slow itself, it just worries about you. Another aspect of this feature is the reminder to take more exercise - you'll know this by its "spinning beachball" icon.
 
Originally posted by groovebuster
Let's talk about it in 10 years again. I'm curious if anything what was predicted today really will have happened then.

(I remember that when I was little they predicted colonies and mining on the moon in the year 2000 as well as cars that run with alternative energy. My travel agent still refuses to sell me a ticket to moon... weird, huh?)

Peace, :cool:

groovebuster

Well yeah :D these things have a habbit of not comming true. Ok - not to continue this too much longer, but I just want to point out that, no - I'm not terribly wealthy, and most companies that do actually to these things tend to be very careful with their budget.

You're right about the thin-client thing - I see that as a move away from desktops too. One company I did work for moved building, replaced every CTR with LCDs, bought smaller desks, and a leased a smaller building. They saved enough rent in 6 months to pay for the LCD up-grade and new desks.

And I'm afraid that new appartments & houses do cost that much a square metre. More if you're living in London or Tokyo. This price is city living at it's cheapest...ofcourse you can get cheaper and slightly bigger homes even in London - but you're living about 1 hour from central London. In the next few years even these places will start to cost much more. Most younger people like me, who still rent, can either affort a bigger house an hour out of London, or a small flat in the centre. Same in Melbourne and most other large cities in the world.

Man, I'm not making this stuff up! The trends are there (or here http://www.business2.com/articles/web/0,1653,42667,00.html - Gartner's - that link in my last post - have stuff on this but it's pay only...). Laptop sales up 6%, desktops down 3%. Worldwide.

It's happening. The only way desktops will survive becoming a poweruser niche will be with wireless displays and a box a-kin to your stereo's.

Anyway...let's just agree to disagree ;)

a.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: UK PowerBooks up, Desktops Down

Originally posted by mim
+ cheap desk 300 pounds (500USD?)
+ chair 200 pounds (350USD?)

gets closer and closer to that powerbook price.

AND, the desktop doesn't let you surf your way to sleep at night. Gotta have the powerbook ;)

a.

You realize that almost every living space in the Western world has a desk and chair, I hope.

And for the record, what about carrying cases? Those cost money.

And even if the Power Mac cost the exact same as the PowerBook, the Power Mac would still be more powerful.

That said, I plan to buy a PowerBook this August, since I'm going to be a college student. A Power Mac may cost less and may have more speed, but I still can't carry it to class :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.