my experience
I spent a month reading up on all the new mac laptops. Once I narrowed it down to a macbook pro (as opposed to macbook air), I decided to go to the store and spend about an hour doing the same exact thing on every laptop (minus the 17 inch). So I went on the internet, viewed some youtube videos, and some photos (generally wildlife and nature that were already in the iphoto library on all the machines). Ok, so right away I was amazed at how much glare/reflection there were on all the glossy macbook pros. The lighting in the store is terrible overhead flourescent lights. I moved over to the 15 inch MBP anti glare and I was quite amazed at how the glare was completely gone, and the picture quality was amazing. I didn't enjoy the gray outline as much as the black, but Im coming from a powerbook g4, 15inch, and so it didn't bother me. Maybe I'm biased because the pb has a matte screen? So after I looked at the ag 15inch I went over to the macbook airs. They were somewhere in the middle of the glossy mbp and the antiglare mbp. I was kind of amazing at how amazing the macbook air felt, looked, etc. If I wanted something more portable, and didn't want something to last a very long time (I want to be able to add RAM, swap hard drives (hdd and ssd), and the macbook, as far as I know, you can't). So in the end I felt like my only reasonable choice was the 15 inch mbp with higher res/antiglare. And the more I looked at the ag screen the more I realized that the ag was a more truthful representation of what you're looking at. The glossy seems too flashy, and honestly just doesn't make sense. The reflections/glare were just terrible. I knew right away that buying them wasn't even an option for me, it hurt my eyes, and frustrated me right away. I hope this helps someone. I guess my concluding remark is to go to the store to see for yourself. I know this was one condition/situation, but it spoke volumes to me about many situations I would come to encounter once I bought it. In fact, I went home and ordered the mbp 15 inch with high res/ag that night. It's on it's way. I think the battle between ag/glossy is a larger argument against accuracy and truth versus flashiness and appeal to the senses? The ag seems so crisp and refined, simple and humble? Anyway, good luck with whatever any of you choose. Now's a good time if you like this current style and the optical drive (whether it's for the actual drive or a hdd/ssd). The base 15mbp seemed like it got the biggest boost for this refresh. Happy mac'ing all.
----------
I currently have the 11" MBA. But what I want is the 15" MBP HiRes anti glare screen. I was just in the store yesterday drooling over it.
When the iMac is on it's last legs I want to go to the 15" and an iPad what ever is out then. To me that seems like the perfect setup.
in the store the other day I was seriously considering either a mba or the 15 inch mbp antiglare. all the mbp glossy screens were immediately out of the question. so i went home and ordered the newest refresh of the 15 mbp w ag. if I didn't have an imac mounted on my wall, I would go with the new 15 inch as my home/desktop replacement, and go for the 11 inch mba (or maybe the 13). the mba's are gorgeous. the display is so nice.....slightly reflective, but much more similar to the ag than the glossy. I don't know how anyone can enjoy those.