I made that exact switch.
I bought the aluminum, cellular S4 instead of stainless thinking I would be upgrading the following year like I usually do with phones.
Fast forward to 2023 and saw no real need to upgrade the watch. Despite wearing it all the time, I rarely used it for much. Reading some
notifications, setting some timers/reminders and checking the time. I just couldn’t justify getting something a bit newer, a bit faster, slightly larger screen and stainless.
I’m glad I waited…
With the Raw Titanium iPhones, the Ultra 2 was a no brainer to compliment each other.
The Ultra 2 is a HUGE upgrade from the S4. Feels entirely new, blazing fast and a battery that never seems to need charging. (Battery on the S4 was roached…)
I’m so glad I went with the Ultra 2 vs the S9, because I think the S9 would not have looked or felt much different besides being faster.
I use the flashlight “action” button all the time at night (despite being a total flashlight EDC nerd. The watch is just easier for “around the house in the dark stuff.”) I use the sleep tracking feature every night cause I only charge like twice a week in the mornings for under 30 min. No way to do that with S4 without lots of planning and charging.
The bigger display, faster processor and cellular also had me leaving the Pro Max behind more often(haven’t used a max/large phone since the X came out). It’s nice to be a bit “more” disconnected but not totally without something for emergencies.
The screen makes the watch more usable for everything, maps, messages, etc.
I have a large Citizen world chronograph. atomic clock radio controlled watch that I actually was sporting for a while before I got the Ultra since I lost the S4 for like a minute.
That made the Ultra not feel very big or heavy at all. It is not heavy, but it is tall. Big mechanical watches can be bigger and heavier across the wrist, but the only thing is the Ultra is a thic boi.
I thought I always had tiny wrists, but at 185mm I guess it is not as small as many people wearing the Ultras.
If a slightly bigger watch is not a concern (still crazy comfy with the Alpine Loop and other bands), then I promise you will not regret the upgrade.