Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

dilap

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Apr 18, 2014
813
60
London, UK
I am currently on a 5s, which I feel is getting a little to old for me, but I do also like the Apple TV. They would both cost me the same because of the value of my current phone, so price doesn't matter.
 
Which do you want?

Kind of an odd paradox you're facing. If it were me, I'd go for the phone but then TV was never a huge thing for me.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MRU
Which do you want me?

Kind of an odd paradox you're facing. If it were me, I'd go for the phone but then TV was never a huge thing for me.

Thanks, I'm leaning towards the 6, but since I'd have to wait till October to get it (buying from USA), I'll have a chance to think about it, and hopefully see a review of the TV.
 
Thanks, I'm leaning towards the 6, but since I'd have to wait till October to get it (buying from USA), I'll have a chance to think about it, and hopefully see a review of the TV.
When October rolls around (which isn't all that far at this stage) see which way you're leaning. Plus you'll have the advantage of reading reviews of both products to help make a more informed decision.
 
You decide, how are we supposed to decide this for you? If you can't decide then it doesn't really sound like you need either.

What I meant was so obvious pros or cons about each device, but I couldn't find anything that bad. I just wanted to hear people's opinions and reasoning.
 
What I meant was so obvious pros or cons about each device, but I couldn't find anything that bad. I just wanted to hear people's opinions and reasoning.

The problem is the two devices are completely independent entities so it's pretty much impossible to compare them unless you go down the lines of ....


Apple TV 4 - Not very portable. Has a really poor battery. Requires additional peripherals like a screen. Really bad cell reception on it. Onscreen keyboard is not very touch sensitive. Really poor camera.

At the end of the day, one is a TV set top box - the other is a phone. They are meant to compliment each other - not be a direct competitors.

Essentially do you want a TV box or a new phone ? That's essentially the only question you need to answer.
 
The problem is the two devices are completely independent entities so it's pretty much impossible to compare them unless you go down the lines of ....


Apple TV 4 - Not very portable. Has a really poor battery. Requires additional peripherals like a screen. Really bad cell reception on it. Onscreen keyboard is not very touch sensitive. Really poor camera.

At the end of the day, one is a TV set top box - the other is a phone. They are meant to compliment each other - not be a direct competitors.

Essentially do you want a TV box or a new phone ? That's essentially the only question you need to answer.

But we don't know much about the TV, which is why I will take maflynn's advice.
 
Go for broke get both! I have a 6+ and a 6S+ on order and Apple TV 3 will be getting the 4 when it's released. They compliment each other very nicely!
 
I am currently on a 5s, which I feel is getting a little to old for me, but I do also like the Apple TV. They would both cost me the same because of the value of my current phone, so price doesn't matter.
No offense, but if you're in a situation where you need to deeply contemplate the spending of $150 then maybe you should be saving your money for a more important things. Fancy phone upgrades and overpriced streaming boxes aren't necessities, they're luxuries for those who can afford it.

Apple is very good at what they do, but one of the things they do best is charge more money for products that do the same thing as much cheaper competitors.
 
No offense, but if you're in a situation where you need to deeply contemplate the spending of $150 then maybe you should be saving your money for a more important things. Fancy phone upgrades and overpriced streaming boxes aren't necessities, they're luxuries for those who can afford it.

Apple is very good at what they do, but one of the things they do best is charge more money for products that do the same thing as much cheaper competitors.

None taken! It would be a birthday present, I'm only 13!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.