So I have had my iPhone 5 since it launched in late 2012 and I purchased AppleCare with it and part of that includes two "incident replacements" in case I break my screen or whatever. Pretty much I can pay $50 bucks and get a whole new phone if I break my screen etc. Well after having my iPhone 5 now for over a year it has gotten roughed up a bit. Mainly because of an OtterBox case I had on it that scratched parts of the screen and the volume buttons feel extremely loose. I would love to pay $50 bucks and get a whole new iPhone 5 that I will use until the iPhone 6 comes out. But my question is will Apple let me just replace my roughed up iPhone 5 for a new one using my $50 dollar incident replacement stuff? Or does my screen actually have to be busted?