I live way out in the woods, so DSL was great when I got it..but now they are bringing Uverse to my neighborhood, so I would like to get off the Dish, they just keep raising my bill each month..
We have had U-Verse for a little over a year and a half now, switched from Comcast when a door-to-door salesman "convinced" us. We did get a great promo rate for a year and also got a lot of cash back in the form of Visa rewards cards. (Like $300 including starz/showtime cards!) We have the U-300 with the fastest internet we can get at my house, 18down/2.5up I think is the speed.
I will say - it depends on your household. We are somewhat satisfied with it. We are one of the furthest houses from their hub so we cannot get the fastest internet, and another big thing is that we can only get 2 or 3 HD streams at one time MAX. Our house has 4 HD TVs. If I record a show on the DVR, my brother records one or watches one, that leaves either 1 or no HD streams left, sure you could watch a standard definition but it doesn't look that great. I've heard the HD quality sucks as it's highly compressed but I'm not a huge quality nazi so it is fine for our viewing. If I wanted to record 2 shows at once, that leaves virtually no wiggle room for anyone else in our house to watch HD t.v whether it be recording their own HD shows or watching them live. It really is a hassle.
If it's just you, or maybe you and a girlfriend/wife, I think you would most likely be okay. Also if don't use DVR or something. You have to look at how many shows you would record or watch live at one point.
Another thing they don't really tell you is that your line coming in is just one big line to be shared by your TVs and Internet/Computers. That means if you have all your HD streams going, your internet speed will suffer. I've read anywhere between 2-6 MBits a HD stream takes out of your speed. I haven't done any official benchmarks and I can say that my internet speeds aren't that great when we have all our TVs on.
The service itself is great, I don't notice any HD problems/compression and I have never had any service outages, not even one. The total home DVR is awesome, I really enjoy it.
You might ask why we keep it vs Comcast or satellite, well, because of the price. While the rewards card cash/promo period expired, we called and asked what they could do about our bill because it shot up so high $$. We are paying $121 (after taxes!) for U-300 (includes starz/showtime!), 4 HD boxes, and the total room DVR, and our internet as well. Nobody else can even come remotely close to that price. Would we prefer Comcast, yes, but to get similar packages it would be well over $200 a month.