Valid trade of iMac to MacBook Pro?

[kildraik]

Would a trade of a 17" Intel Imac be a valid trade for a MacBook Pro? Would they be acceptable in normal conditions, such as both of the opposite parties would want that computer?

 

[andrewheard]

Its a valid trade for whoever is getting the MacBook Pro.

 

[technicolor]

Its a valid trade for whoever is getting the MacBook Pro.

basically


This is not at all a fair trade. Whoever gets the MBP is making out like a bandit.

 

[Mernak]

Its completely fair....assuming the iMac has 2 GB RAM and a 500 GB HD and the macbook pro has not been upgraded at all

 

[dmw007]

This is not at all a fair trade. Whoever gets the MBP is making out like a bandit.

Yep, that is pretty much the case.

 

[Fleetwood Mac]

I think this would dependant on the use of both machines, as well as whine/heat related issues on the MBP.