Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MasterM6

macrumors member
Original poster
Mar 9, 2009
30
0
I have decided to buy a WESTERN DIGITAL VELOCIRAPTOR 300GB 3.5# 10K RPM SATA/300 16MB does it work in Mac Pro 2009? Remember reading something about one version not working.

It is marked as WD3000HLFS.
 
I have decided to buy a WESTERN DIGITAL VELOCIRAPTOR 300GB 3.5# 10K RPM SATA/300 16MB does it work in Mac Pro 2009? Remember reading something about one version not working.

It is marked as WD3000HLFS.

The HLFS model is the correct model with the backplane ready to mount into any of the standard Mac Pro drives.

FWIW, the 6400AAKS is 90% the speed for a fraction of the cost. YMMV though.
 
The HLFS model is the correct model with the backplane ready to mount into any of the standard Mac Pro drives.

FWIW, the 6400AAKS is 90% the speed for a fraction of the cost. YMMV though.

Sorry but I didn´t understand much of your last sentence there....

But thanks for the help :D
 
YMMV = Your milage may vary.

PS: I've got a 300Gb Veloci in my 2009 Mac Pro and IT FILES.

Although not as quick as a SSD I guess!
 
I have decided to buy a WESTERN DIGITAL VELOCIRAPTOR 300GB 3.5# 10K RPM SATA/300 16MB does it work in Mac Pro 2009? Remember reading something about one version not working.

It is marked as WD3000HLFS.

I've got the 150gb version in mine, works perfectly fine. Great as a system/app drive!
 
I have decided to buy a WESTERN DIGITAL VELOCIRAPTOR 300GB 3.5# 10K RPM SATA/300 16MB does it work in Mac Pro 2009? Remember reading something about one version not working.

It is marked as WD3000HLFS.

I'm running 3 in a RAID 0 stripe for my user files. It is very fast! :D
 
Boneoh, what do you use for a startup drive? I've been thinking about RAIDing a few VRs together for a home volume.
 
Boneoh, what do you use for a startup drive? I've been thinking about RAIDing a few VRs together for a home volume.

I'm using the Intel X25M for the OS. Here is a link to another post that has the benchmarks. I am very pleased. Photoshop CS4 starts in 2 to 3 seconds. :D

Disk benchmarks https://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?p=7255329&Disktester#post7255329

Memory stress test https://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?p=7261725&stress+test#post7261725

Geekbench http://browse.geekbench.ca/geekbench2/view/116989
 
I've got the GLFS.

Does that mean i'd have to buy the mounts in order to fit mine into my mac pro?

I'm not sure what type of mounts are available, but the "G" model will not plug directly into the backplane using the standard disk trays in the MP. I found out the hard way :eek:, and did a simple exchange for the "H" model. :)
 
I've got the GLFS.

Does that mean i'd have to buy the mounts in order to fit mine into my mac pro?
In your case ('08 model), YES. :) MaxUpgrades makes a sled that works with the WD3000GLFS models. (Remove the drive from the aluminum mount, and attach it to the mount, then plug it into the drive bay).
 
What do you think would lead to more speed benefit:

1. Going for a 2.93 quad instead of a 2.66 quad.
2. Getting a 2.66 quad and buy a WD VelicoRaptor as system disk.

What about the noise of the VR vs the Caviar Black? To be neglected?!

Till now I planned to let the original system disk in and get 3x1TB Caviar Black for position 2-4.
 
What do you think would lead to more speed benefit:

1. Going for a 2.93 quad instead of a 2.66 quad.
2. Getting a 2.66 quad and buy a WD VelicoRaptor as system disk.

What about the noise of the VR vs the Caviar Black? To be neglected?!

Till now I planned to let the original system disk in and get 3x1TB Caviar Black for position 2-4.

Buy the Quad 2.93 and buy the VR when you got the money ;)
 
Buy the Quad 2.93 and buy the VR when you got the money ;)
I - being honest - closed my posting with: please don´t say 2.93 and VR :D
Than I decided to leave out the note. Better shouldn´t have done that :rolleyes:
That's what I did. It cost me $200.00 (after a $30.00 mail in rebate) for the 300 GB VR. Definitely worth it.
Just coming up from the cellar where I went for crying out loud my frustration.
The VelociRaptor costs minimum 300 USD in Germany. The prices here make me go crazy.
Buying a Mac Pro in the US I could go for 4 x WD VR RAID 0 and still had money left for a lot of backup solutions.

But as I don´t - turn back to the question:

More speed by

1. 2.93 quad instead of a 2.66 quad ??
2. 2.66 quad and VelicoRaptor as system disk ??
 
1. 2.93 quad instead of a 2.66 quad ??
2. 2.66 quad and VelicoRaptor as system disk ??

TBH dude, after having the same debate I went for the 2.66.

The 18% increase in UK HE price to the 2.93 didn't match the 3% single core or 9-10% multicore increase in performance from the benchies.

The £300 has been set aside for a year or twos time when the 32nm refresh come out, it will probably be the same amount as I loose on the machine itself over the next period.

Buy the 2.66 :) Oh and the veloci you can just hear over the fans when idle but seeking you can defiantly hear it, doesn't bother me, its a healthy click although not quite as good as the old SCSI Ultra III 9gb drives you used to get :p
 
Thanks for your assessment, Concorde Rules!

The same here in Germany: +20,0% increase of the price for 2.93 instead 2.66 quad.
And the other data has been shown before also: 2-8% increase of speed.

The VelociRaptor is 11% of the system´s price. Don´t know about the speed increase?!
Had a good link comparing some different starter disks, but unfortunately lost it.

2.66 quad 6GB RAM + VR = € 2.333 (edu price)
2.93 quad 6GB RAM = € 2.506 (edu price)
 
2.66 quad 6GB RAM + VR = € 2.333 (edu price)
2.93 quad 6GB RAM = € 2.506 (edu price)

In Belgium, I take the quad 2.93/6GB/HD4870 + VR all for around 2900-2950 €

I'm really happy, the OS and app on the VR for max performances
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.