1. You get more with the higher price.
What more do you get? Do you get to roll over your minutes? Do you get unlimited mobile-2-mobile?
You could give me the whole, verizon has broader coverage. But honestly I live in major metro. area. When I travel I only go to large towns.
2. My data speeds are faster or equivalent to my old AT&T speeds on the iPhone 4. Not to mention, I can actually use the data, because I've got decent signal.
I only have to direct you to the multiple threads on this forum where Verizon has slower data speeds. And again not an issue unless your living in rural communites.
4. The only feature I know that's "crippled" is simultaneous voice and data, which I believe is a feature, not features as you say. Other than that, it's the same phone, with the addition of Mobile Hot Spot, which AT&T does not yet have (I am aware that it is coming.).
Simultaneous data and voice is huge. There are many times when I'm scheduling a meeting, and I need access to google calendar, or txt, or reference an email, or look up a drug while on a phone call.
Tethering is already available via JB, and is quite simple to use.
5. I don't think there's any uncertainty. The current Verizon phone has a GSM chip in it. It's obvious the next one will too, and it will be a combined device, or at least the same internals with a different antenna for the other network. No way would Apple not upgrade both networks. The only way they would not release a Verizon iPhone this June is if they didn't release a GSM one either.
Verizon execs and apple could have easily come out and said "there will/will not be no new Iphone on verizon in 4 months. Instead they chose to leave it up to the consumer to decide to get the phone now and risk it, or just wait.
I would have loved to switch to verizon. But when I started looking at costs, features, data speeds, and weighing them against cons (occasional dropped call). It was a no brainer.
I am glad the phone is on verizon. I love the competition and the choice. I just think if Verizon was serious, they could have done a lot better.