Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!

argo063

macrumors member
Original poster
Aug 7, 2010
71
0
Hey people

Got some VHS tapes I was to covert into digital. But I want the highest quality.

Number 1 way
Have DVD record. Could plug in VHS player to it and press record . Then convert the DVD to a digital file. This is alot of work and I think not the best quality because you burn to DVD.

Number 2 way
Have a pvr what can record on hard drive so could do it that way

Number 3 way
But a converter eg the video out cables to USB or FireWire .

What would be the best way for top quality?
Got both macs and widows with loin and window 7.

Thanks :)
 
Nov 28, 2010
22,670
28
located
3 is the best way, as you might not be able to read the file from way 2.

____________________________________________________________

Maybe have a look at Advanced Search to find dozens of threads about capturing VHS footage on your Mac:
____________________________________________________________
 
Comment

argo063

macrumors member
Original poster
Aug 7, 2010
71
0
That what I throught. So what the best unit for quality. ?
 
Comment

mBox

macrumors 68020
Jun 26, 2002
2,312
64
Blackmagic Intensity Pro

The unit is cheap and under 300.
Works with Avid, Adobe PremierePro and FCPX but under Lion.
It has its own capture/record software if the above dont exist for you.
 
Comment

Magrathea

macrumors regular
Aug 21, 2008
193
0
I did this a month or two ago and if I recall correctly I connected up my VHS machine to my DV camera via s S-VHS cable. Then I put the DV camera in a special mode and then connected the camera to my mac via FW.

You must have a VHS machine that has a svhs out, if you have a crappy old one with just RCA you'll be SOL :)


I was then able to use imovie to import the tapes directly.
 
Comment

jcb10

macrumors regular
May 14, 2008
127
12
I found No. 3 quite simple with the EyeTV Hybrid ($150) sold at both Apple Stores and online.
 
Comment

mBox

macrumors 68020
Jun 26, 2002
2,312
64
I did this a month or two ago and if I recall correctly I connected up my VHS machine to my DV camera via s S-VHS cable. Then I put the DV camera in a special mode and then connected the camera to my mac via FW.

You must have a VHS machine that has a svhs out, if you have a crappy old one with just RCA you'll be SOL :)


I was then able to use imovie to import the tapes directly.
This was the only cheap way back in the day :)
 
Comment

argo063

macrumors member
Original poster
Aug 7, 2010
71
0
The unit is cheap and under 300.
Works with Avid, Adobe PremierePro and FCPX but under Lion.
It has its own capture/record software if the above dont exist for you.

Can you some how compare the quality with a back magic and the pvr way?
As well is the USB 3 on back magic work with USB 2? If not will have to use thunder bolt on laptop .
 
Comment

mBox

macrumors 68020
Jun 26, 2002
2,312
64
Can you some how compare the quality with a back magic and the pvr way?
As well is the USB 3 on back magic work with USB 2? If not will have to use thunder bolt on laptop .
wish I could, the BM card was for work, Id love some kind of PVR at home. Only one I have is for cable and have never used it as a external recorder.
 
Comment

mcpix

macrumors 6502
May 13, 2005
295
74
I do this every day and the best unit I've found for VHS is the Canopus ADVC110.

It does a great job and is bus powered. Plus if this is a one time only project they are very popular on eBay, and you can get most of your money back!

I also agree with the other poster that the best way is to use a VHS deck with an S-VHS output. Most JVC decks work well for this.
 
Comment

argo063

macrumors member
Original poster
Aug 7, 2010
71
0
In the end using a Dxtreme DX 380 HD. Just got it for another reason. Works great and great quality. As well I can copy the files over net work. What works well.
 
Comment

WRP

macrumors 6502a
Jul 20, 2011
511
2
Boston
BEST QUALITY?

get a capture card, rent a good VHS player with quality out and capture that way. Something like this....

65918_444948275635_632070635_5810203_8166353_n.jpg


But I know you aren't going to go that heavy :D
 
Comment

argo063

macrumors member
Original poster
Aug 7, 2010
71
0
On a bit differnt subject . Of scanners. What scanners are the best these days? Got a 600 dpi one at moment what good but then I see ones that are 9000 dpi . Are they that much better?
 
Comment

Lo123

macrumors newbie
Dec 30, 2013
1
0
I do this every day and the best unit I've found for VHS is the Canopus ADVC110.

It does a great job and is bus powered. Plus if this is a one time only project they are very popular on eBay, and you can get most of your money back!

I also agree with the other poster that the best way is to use a VHS deck with an S-VHS output. Most JVC decks work well for this.

Reviews look good! I'm almost sold.
I need to convert to digital and upload to Mac (iMovie), then export to an external hard drive, then upload to PC where I'll finally edit the movies (don't ask why - long story). I'm suspecting that this will lead to headaches over file conversions, but I really have no idea. Any reason suggestions or reasons why the Canopus wouldn't be a good starting point for my process? Thanks
 
Comment

mBox

macrumors 68020
Jun 26, 2002
2,312
64
Canopus to PC dont work?
Or iMovie for acquisition for approval then sent to you for PC editing?
Your problem will be the iMovie format to PC.
 
Comment

aaronvan

Suspended
Dec 21, 2011
1,350
9,350
República Cascadia
Well, depending on how many VHS tapes you have, I would consider taking the tapes to a transfer service. Some drugstores will even do tape-to-disc. On the West Coast they seem to average around $25-30 per tape-to-DVD. However, that would get expensive if you have boxes of tapes and might not be the quality that you seek. Color correction, audio equalization, etc will add to the cost, too.
 
Comment

macmania1

macrumors newbie
Feb 6, 2014
2
0
I want to convert VHS tapes to digital files, preferably QuickTime - not iMovie.
I don't have a VCR so most options here won't work for me. I don't want to convert VHS to DVD then to QT - I just want to convert VHS to digital video file, preferably with USB access. Any suggestions on what equipment to get?
 
Comment

fa8362

macrumors 65816
Jul 7, 2008
1,343
58
I want to convert VHS tapes to digital files, preferably QuickTime - not iMovie.
I don't have a VCR so most options here won't work for me. I don't want to convert VHS to DVD then to QT - I just want to convert VHS to digital video file, preferably with USB access. Any suggestions on what equipment to get?

Without a VCR, none of the options will work. Paying someone to do it for you only makes sense if you're doing only a few tapes. Otherwise, buy the VCR and Canopus unit, then sell them when you're finished. EyeTV is great for recording HD TV from cable or antenna, but garbage for recording VHS. With EyeTV. your digital file will look significantly worse than the tape.
 
Comment

kelub

macrumors regular
Jun 15, 2010
136
45
I picked up a "Geniatech iGrabber One Touch Video Grabber" off of Amazon sometime last year - it's $40 and it does the job well. Plugs in via USB and has RCA connections. You'll definitely need a VCR, but you can go to a thrift store and pick one up for really cheap. Alternatively, see if someone you know with one will let you borrow it - there are still plenty of people out there who have them.

Quality is going to be a bit moot since a VCR isn't going to have great quality to begin with - you're talking about a 480i image at its best, so don't set your expectations too high.

It's been a bit since I messed with it so I don't remember exactly what the output format was, but I think I had some different options, and you can always use handbrake or something similar to change it if necessary.
 
Comment

macmania1

macrumors newbie
Feb 6, 2014
2
0
thanks folks. I finally got a vcr, I looked at the iGrabber, then the EZgrabber2, by the same company. I didn't see a big difference between the 2 but EZgrabber 2 is less expensive. Since I'll run this video into my computer, I on't need to connect to tv first, right?
 
Comment

aaronvan

Suspended
Dec 21, 2011
1,350
9,350
República Cascadia
thanks folks. I finally got a vcr, I looked at the iGrabber, then the EZgrabber2, by the same company. I didn't see a big difference between the 2 but EZgrabber 2 is less expensive. Since I'll run this video into my computer, I on't need to connect to tv first, right?

The EZgrabber2 is cheaper but I don't see where it is OS X compatible. In fact, many of the reviewers complain that it has issues with Windows 7. That makes me wonder how well this company supports their products. Also, the iGrapper seems to have disturbingly large number of negative reviews, too. I would be cautious about purchasing anything from this company and do a lot of research.
 
Comment

monokakata

macrumors 68000
May 8, 2008
1,930
443
Ithaca, NY
It's more expensive than anything you're looking at, but if you want something that, as the saying goes, "just works," then take a look at this BlackMagic Design unit:

http://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/produ...Design_VIDREC_Video_Recorder_USB_Capture.html

I used one to transfer probably 50 hours of VHS material, and it was flawless.

I used the s-video output from a Panasonic AG1980 recorder, to try squeezing as much quality from those VHS tapes as I could.
 
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.