I have been giving it some thought about keeping since I knew it was coming up to renew. I liked the fact that my music was with me all the time but every time I went to use it, it did not work and this was on my iPhone 4 and iPhone 5. It would show the song information and every thing but it mostly just sit there like I paused it or something and wouldn't play...sometimes it would but mostly not. I never called Apple about the issues and just hoped that the service would eventually start working as they got better. Has anyone else had experience like I did do? Are you keeping or letting it expire?