Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPad Pro What are the pros and cons moving photos and videos from a M1 iPad Pro to an external storage via direct connection vs. PC with iTunes?
- Thread starter hajime
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I've had corruption issues in the past with copying data/images to exFAT external storage. My long thread on this with others experiences -
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/file-corruption-on-copy-to-external-storage.2235171/
This may be behind us now but it has made me very wary of using this path with the native Files app (no issues when using the third party FileBrowser Pro).
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/file-corruption-on-copy-to-external-storage.2235171/
This may be behind us now but it has made me very wary of using this path with the native Files app (no issues when using the third party FileBrowser Pro).
It almost feel like apple is intentionally Making external drive support bad to incentivise more people to go for iCloud or higher capacity models.
So better to just connect the M1 iPad Pro to a PC which is connected to an external storage. Then use iTunes to copy all the photos and videos there. Then, delete all the photos and videos from the iPad?
Yes, like many things, they intentionally do such and such to make people buy more of their products. it is Apple’s style under Tim.
You might as well just use iPad as an external storage Rather than trying to use external storage through iPad.
I use FileBrowser Pro to copy to external exFAT SSDs in lieu of Files and have never had a corruption problem with it. I do verify that the copy has been good before deleting anything, no matter the copy method. But iTunes is a trustworthy alternative.
Connected to a PC/Mac, files will copy off it at USB 2 speeds.
Connected to an external SSD, files will copy off it at USB 3 speeds.
If you have a lot of data, it’d be faster to copy to a drive and then copy from that drive to the computer.
Good point. My iPad Pro is a 256 GB version. I took many photos and videos with it. I don’t need them to be on the machine all the time. Trying to move them somewhere else.
Given that I don’t need to do this often, I guess USB 2 speed may be OK.
I don’t quite understand. My iPad was full. I was not able to take any video with it until I deleted some files.
Why not move them to Google Drive or Google Photos? Or iCloud Photos. You can them download them elsewhere for a backup.
What I mean is since iPad external drive support is horrible and can corrupt Files plus not handing spinning HDD properly, it is a much safer bet to regularly transfer your data from iPad to a computer than trying to transfer data from iPad to an external drive.
Thanks. Actually, I did not expect that I ran out of storage so soon.
Is connecting a HDD directly to an iPad the most dangerous thing to do especially iPad OS does not have a Reject button?
I don't need to have those files in a compute. Any storage that is reliable is fine.
In that case, I’d suggest buying an external USB-C SSD, getting it formatted to apple file system on a Mac and then copying your files to it. As I understand it, while the Apple Files app is a little less than reliable when copying to ExFAT formatted drives, it’s quite safe copying to apfs.
Unfortunately, this doesn't work if you have a PC environment, not Mac, as I do and as I assumed the OP does from his initial post.
I snooped their post history a little before making that suggestion, they have an older 17" MBP that should be fine to format a drive with. Possibly not APFS depending on their OS version but certainly HFS+
That's what I've been using at home, too, both to Win11 laptop and NAS.
That is right. If I have to go through a computer, that would be a Windows PC. I don't use my MacBook Pro 17" anymore.
No desire to use iCloud and turn on Optimize Photo Storage? My photos are priceless to me so the cloud storage allows me to sleep at night.