As long as I can make the classics run (natively or emulation), I'm good.
For me, the Golden Age of gaming lasted from about 1985 to around 2001 or so, with the real meat of the era being in the late 80s to early 90s.
I'll make an exception for Morrowind in 2002 because with mods and all it was really able to draw me in. But by then it was pretty much over for me and "new" games. Big on graphics, short on story.
These were the real gems of those days (and they still stand the test of time):
Maniac Mansion (1987)
Zak McKracken and the Alien Mindbenders (1988)
Defender of the Crown (1986)
F-19 Stealth (1989)
F-14 Tomcat (1988)
Pirates! (1987)
Pirates! GOLD (1993)
Civilization I (1991)
Civilization II (1996)
(I'm not sure how to feel about CIV III and IV. Too graphicky, but they do work.)
Rise of the Dragon (1991)
Fallout (1997)
Fallout 2 (1998)
Escape Velocity: Nova (2002)
(Although I think the Total War series is quite brilliant, let's be fair, though I've only played Shogun and Rome.)
Interesting to note that these were the days when the game manuals (maps, extras and all) were almost as important and central to one's enjoyment of the games as the games themselves. I recall the Pirates! manual increased my interest in the game and entire historical period a hundredfold. Games of this era left so much to the imagination. I miss that.
I think games really lost it for me when they tried to mirror our visual and spatial reality by going (or attempting to go) 3D.