well, this thread is right up my alley
For the stuff you want to do, the MBPr sounds like the logical selection. If you want to do more complicated stuff in the future with plugins like element 3D, lights, cameras, expressions/scripts, camera tracking and so on and so forth, it won't be enough in the long run. Even though the MBPr is a powerul machine and can hold its own, please read what the guy who ran the WeWantANewMacPro campaign in response to a question I sent him about the MBPr.
- December 3, 2013
12/3, 12:15am
We Want a New Macpro
i'm having issues with my 2012 MBPr and Premiere and AE. The machine is definitely fast but it doesn't seem to play well with the Adobe apps. I don't know if the integrated graphics are the issue. I'm constantly quitting Premiere because video will just stop playing. Ae doesn't recognize the GPU as CUDA capable (and I've tried all the hacks). I've even had problems with Premiere when I have too many Safari tabs open!!!
Not sure if these issues are OS problems or CC problems. I would bet its Adobe's fault though. Their coding seems to be geared towards the PC/Windows world and cobbled together for the Mac as an afterthought.
Can't comment on C4D. I've done some renders in C4D but not enough to really know if it works well.
FCPX and Motion work great but I haven't done too much there either.
The 2013 might fare a bit better because the GPU chipset has been upgraded. Maybe Adobe CC will like this better.
I guess it depends on what software you are running. I'm able to be productive on the MBPr and Adobe CC but I feel like Im constantly fighting with the software. I'm sure FCPX is airtight because its Apple software on Apple hardware and the Apple OS. Forget Avid. I don't know about the 2013 model.
I'm going to wipe my harddirve again and reinstall to see if that eliminates the issues I'm having. I'll keep you posted.
Maybe these have been solved 2 years later.
Anyway, on a more general note, make sure to enable your disc cache in AE preferences.
If you're already getting nifty with AE, I would really suggest the following plugins & scripts
Scripts
ease and wizz (great for keying)
expression timeline
bg renderer
Plugins
trapcode particular
element 3d
rowbyte plexus
red giant color suite
zaxwerks 3d flag
i7-5930k 3.50Ghz (6core)
64gb ddr4 ram
gf gtx titan black 6gb ddr5
3 lg monitors
wacom tablet
ssds all over, mechanical for backups & archiving only
adobe software CC, not CC 2014 nor 2015 due to known issues