Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Internal disk (hourly): TM and CCC
External SSDs (hourly): CCC
Offsite (daily): Arq to B2 and OneDrive
Local synchronisation (daily): CCC and ChronoSync
Hi gilby101. I know it’s been a while since you posted this, but I am researching backup for my Mac. I use Time Machine. For offsite, I had Carbonite for years (former Windows user), currently have Sugar Sync expiring on 9/2/25. I don’t want to renew. I was checking out iDrive, but then I thought can’t I use OneDrive, I have a TB with plenty of space available. I found some info online for how to backup the Mac files & folders (that’s all I would need).
Setting Up OneDrive on Your Mac
  1. Install OneDrive: Download the OneDrive sync app for Mac from the Microsoft website. Uninstall any previous versions from the Mac App Store.
  2. Sign In: Open the OneDrive app and sign in with your Microsoft account.
  3. Enable Full Disk Access: Go to System Preferences > Security & Privacy > Privacy. Add OneDrive to the list of applications with Full Disk Access
Full Disk Access!!? Is that secure? I suppose any backup app requires that……

I wanted to ask, how do you backup to OneDrive? And is it a good replacement for the other apps (idrive, backblaze, carbonite?)thanks! donna
 
how do you backup to OneDrive?
I don't have the OneDrive sync app installed. It is very much cloud storage with synchronisation - not backup.

I use Arq with OneDrive as a storage location. This uses MS's API to connect directly to OneDrive servers.

But, I find that OneDrive is not a good storage location for Arq. In particular it can be slow and does sometimes have errors. I believe this to be because MS is not very friendly to non-MS software using OneDrive.

Storage comparison:

Arq (and others like Duplicacy) can connect to various cloud storages. I only use OneDrive because it is included with MS365. I have found GoogleDrive to be much better (reliable and faster). I also tried B2 and Wasabi - good and reliable but their network performance is not good when you live in another continent (Australia).

Application comparison:

Arq compared with all-in-one packages (Application and storage) like Backblaze, iDrive, Carbonite, Crashplan, etc.):

Arq is considerably better than any of them in terms of fidelity of restored file attributes (creation dates, finder tags, extended attributes, etc.). Some years ago I questioned Backblaze Support about this - the response indicated that ignoring all file attributes except for the data in files is a virtue. I didn't agree, so never seriously considered Backblaze backup.

Backblaze is very much an install, let it run and don't worry about it - until you need to restore. Any configuration is difficult. A good thing if you find the concept of backup somewhat incomprehensible - any backup is better than none. Arq does require configuration, but is great once you get to understand it.

Arq gives you control over how long old versions of files are retained. I find that comforting. Arq is like Time Machine in that it keeps snapshot of your file system for as long as you specify or have space on the storage.

iDrive (and Carbonite?) have a reputation for throttling performance as your backup size grows. Neither, in my view, are well suited to Macs. This is in general true of any product which is focused on the Windows market.

I did use Crashplan, but it went through a phase of ignoring home use - that was when I change to Arq. From snippets on the web, I understand they are again more interested in home use.

The big negative of Arq: Key person dependency. It is very much a one-person product (single developer and some email support staff). This is a risk to future development of the product but not, I consider, to the current product or to the backups I already have. Arq also went through a bad phase with versions 5 and 6 - it almost destroyed the product. Version 7 seems very solid.
 
I had been very happy with Backblaze for several years, but more recently ran into a big problem where it basically consumes all of my RAM but just thrashes and doesn't back anything up.

bz_mem.png


Apparently, this is the problem

"Backblaze Computer Backup maintains a file on your computer called bzfileids.dat. When Backblaze Computer Backup backs up your files, it loads the bzfileids.dat file into RAM to run a checksum before uploading your files to the server. If you back up an extremely large number of files, or if your computer has used the Backblaze Computer Backup software for a very long time, the bzfileids.dat file may become too large to be fully loaded into RAM"

Have been able to get it working a few times after running by itself over night, but my primary Mac is very heavily used, often exporting large numbers of files while I sleep. Support might be able to help, but just haven't wanted to take the time. I think backup software should "just work" without a lot of troubleshooting or support. I plan to bail and find something else when my subscription comes up for renewal next time.

Very well could be a fluke related to my own specific setup and usage, and like I said, it was trouble-free for a long time. But it's about time for me to look at some alternatives.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.