Glad to see you are giving it a try but forcing yourself to use it? What exactly are you doing with it?
I have mine set up right now with the following glances: heartbeat, battery, calendar, activity, and a water app that I am trying out.
For Notifications I have it set for Activities (stand reminder, goal completions, achievements, weekly summary); Calendar (show alerts on and the rest are on too); I haven't turned on Mail figuring I'd rather see that on my phone; Maps (show turns on) although I haven't really spent the time exploring this on my watch yet, keep meaning to try out the walking and driving maps; Messages (use a lot and have set to show alerts, sound and haptic turned on, and I repeat alerts twice); Passbook and Apple Pay (I only wish my stupid bank would join the program already; I haven't added my Walgreens etc cards yet but could, not traveling right now so don't need for boarding passes); Phone (set on for alerts, sound and haptic); Photos (haven't used any space for this, for now would rather just see on my phone); Reminders (alert on as well as sound and haptic).
As for the apps on my watch face, I have and used Activities, Workout, Timer, Alarm, Stopwatch, Messages, Weather (although I want to buy DarkSkies and use that), stocks, and a water app. I know I will use the remote feature for the camera and Apple TV but haven't yet. World clock has been a quick convenience at times. Calendar of course. Not a big music person but will eventually make use of it when I get a bluetooth headset and want to go walking. I have my go to contacts on my Friends set up. A lot of times I will use Siri to set alarms, make quick calls, send iMessages, etc. instead of accessing the apps by touch.
What kind of things do you do on a regular daily basis? Maybe people could suggest settings for you. It really should be customized to your habits where you don't need to have to pull out your phone all the time. It does take some thought about how best to set it up for yourself. For me it's just such a natural extension that I don't pull out my iPhone as much and don't have to carry it around with me all over my house and yard.