Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

jamesjingyi

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Dec 20, 2011
853
164
UK
This has probably been posted before, but with the launch of the 5S looming, its become the time for me to gear up with the facts which will/should be the same... What does your iPhone look like now, (nearly) a year on, especially the heavily criticised black ones. Are they in good condition or do they look worse than your 3GS that fell out of the window?

Pictures would be really helpful :D

Thanks

James

 
Here's mine. I have some scuffing on three edges but that's due to my own stupidity of dropping the phone on concrete when I was bent down. Everything else has been wear and tear. One chamfered edge has worn the black off because my phone rests in a business card holder on that edge all day.

No scratches on the back or front as I don't lay my phone down on rough surfaces or slide it around. No dents, no dings. There are a few nicks though.
 

Attachments

  • 201308251518_238.jpg
    201308251518_238.jpg
    308.6 KB · Views: 115
  • 201308251519_239.jpg
    201308251519_239.jpg
    301.4 KB · Views: 99
  • 201308251520_240.jpg
    201308251520_240.jpg
    321.9 KB · Views: 118
  • 201308251521_241.jpg
    201308251521_241.jpg
    302.8 KB · Views: 110
  • 201308251522_242.jpg
    201308251522_242.jpg
    315.4 KB · Views: 110
All pics taken with my HTC Touch Pro, which my iPhone 5 replaced as my primary phone. Flash was on so don't assume all the white is scuffing.
 

Attachments

  • 201308251522_243.jpg
    201308251522_243.jpg
    297.1 KB · Views: 91
  • 201308251523_244.jpg
    201308251523_244.jpg
    374 KB · Views: 98
  • 201308251523_245.jpg
    201308251523_245.jpg
    345 KB · Views: 84
  • 201308251523_246.jpg
    201308251523_246.jpg
    404.9 KB · Views: 94
All pics taken with my HTC Touch Pro, which my iPhone 5 replaced as my primary phone. Flash was on so don't assume all the white is scuffing.

Thanks for your reply! Do you feel the iPhone was a less durable phone? Has that put you off buying another one? Would you consider the white model instead?
 
C'mon guy! photos of a metallic device with the flash turned on?

Anyway, mine looks pretty much new cause I just had it swapped for a non working rear camera.

Before the swap it had specks and some loss of coloration along the chamfered edge. Also had a couple dings from being dropped on asphalt with no case. Rear casing was starting to show very subtle fading as well.

Overall I think it's quite a durable phone. I never dropped my 4 or 4S phones so I never had cracked glass on those but I know many who did. I dropped my iPhone 5 quite a few times some with case and some without and it has help up quite nicely. I didn't go for the AppleCare plan on it either.
 
Thanks for your reply! Do you feel the iPhone was a less durable phone? Has that put you off buying another one? Would you consider the white model instead?
LOL!

Sorry, not laughing at you. My previous phone was an HTC Touch Pro. Plastic, except for the chrome band. Originally a high end business phone it saw a lot of drops, one from stomach height to sidewalk concrete where it slid on it's face about five feet. The last drop caused a bend in the chrome strip around the LCD.

So, compared to how this phone was by this point my iPhone 5 is in excellent condition. With my stupid mistakes excluded, I'm ok with the wear. It's all been finish issues. No dents or anything like that. The only other phone I have is a 3GS and that, while well taken care of by my sister, has a small crack in the back by the 30-pin port. So, compared to all of this I think my iPhone 5 is holding up well.

But I was never an iPhone 4/4S owner. Some people here swear by them. I can't speak to that because I never liked them enough to want one.

White? No. Not me. I prefer the black, 2001 monolith look. I don't mind the scuffing. My wife on the other hand, I just bought a white iPhone 5 for because she wanted white. Flawless out of the box.

I would definitely buy another black iPhone 5. I'll probably buy the one Apple releases next year when my contract is up.

----------

C'mon guy! photos of a metallic device with the flash turned on?

I had two phones with cameras with which to take pictures. The iPhone 3GS I had doesn't have a flash and the camera stinks. My Touch Pro has a better camera and it was dark. My point was just to provide an overview.
 
Have had if naked since release day. It's scratched so badly on the edges and a few dents on the edges too.

The back and all the glass is flawless. Haven't got any noticeable scratches on the glass tbh.

Hoping something fails on it soon so I can swap it out lol.
 
LOL!

Sorry, not laughing at you. My previous phone was an HTC Touch Pro. Plastic, except for the chrome band. Originally a high end business phone it saw a lot of drops, one from stomach height to sidewalk concrete where it slid on it's face about five feet. The last drop caused a bend in the chrome strip around the LCD.

So, compared to how this phone was by this point my iPhone 5 is in excellent condition. With my stupid mistakes excluded, I'm ok with the wear. It's all been finish issues. No dents or anything like that. The only other phone I have is a 3GS and that, while well taken care of by my sister, has a small crack in the back by the 30-pin port. So, compared to all of this I think my iPhone 5 is holding up well.

But I was never an iPhone 4/4S owner. Some people here swear by them. I can't speak to that because I never liked them enough to want one.

White? No. Not me. I prefer the black, 2001 monolith look. I don't mind the scuffing. My wife on the other hand, I just bought a white iPhone 5 for because she wanted white. Flawless out of the box.

I would definitely buy another black iPhone 5. I'll probably buy the one Apple releases next year when my contract is up.

----------



I had two phones with cameras with which to take pictures. The iPhone 3GS I had doesn't have a flash and the camera stinks. My Touch Pro has a better camera and it was dark. My point was just to provide an overview.

So the chamfers are the most susceptible to scratching?

----------

Have had if naked since release day. It's scratched so badly on the edges and a few dents on the edges too.

The back and all the glass is flawless. Haven't got any noticeable scratches on the glass tbh.

Hoping something fails on it soon so I can swap it out lol.

Did you use it as usual? Would you mind posting pictures? Would be really helpful!

----------

C'mon guy! photos of a metallic device with the flash turned on?

Anyway, mine looks pretty much new cause I just had it swapped for a non working rear camera.

Before the swap it had specks and some loss of coloration along the chamfered edge. Also had a couple dings from being dropped on asphalt with no case. Rear casing was starting to show very subtle fading as well.

Overall I think it's quite a durable phone. I never dropped my 4 or 4S phones so I never had cracked glass on those but I know many who did. I dropped my iPhone 5 quite a few times some with case and some without and it has help up quite nicely. I didn't go for the AppleCare plan on it either.

Did it look older than it was? Just wondering you see because I dont want to be faced with a device that is half a year old but looks older than my 4...
 
So the chamfers are the most susceptible to scratching?
Well…the word I would use would be chafing. But yes, in my opinion. It's where the glass meets the metal and on one edge only (the side I mentioned) it's been rubbed to silver.

But that's because it sits in this business card holder and goes in and out of it during the 8-9 hours I spend here at work.
 
Ive always chosen to have a bumper on mine, with a cheap set of Carbon Fibre decal antenna strips.

The only marks are where i tired out a metal cleave bumper and the metal volume rocker marked the black on the original rocker.

Soon removed that !

That said i don't really use the bumper to protect the sides, but instead to add grip to keep hold of the slippery sucker !!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.