Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

gman71882

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 12, 2005
404
0
Houston, Tx
What would be the Quickest External Drive setup for a 15" Macbook Pro?
This will be used for Video editing. (FCP, Imovie, After effects):

External SATA2 HD with a Firewire 800 express card/34?
OR
External SATA2 HD with a eSATA express card/34 :confused:

Some sites list the fw/800 transfer speed @ upto 800 mb/s while others list it as 80 mb/s
sataII is supposed to be 3.0GB/s but ive found it listed as 300MB/s on some sites???? Who is correct?
I can get a eSATA Express card from FirmteK

CoolDrives.com
lists speeds like this:
USB2 = USB 2.0 port rated at 48MB/s
1394a FW400 = FireWire 400 port rated at up to 40MB/s
1394b FW800 = FireWire 800 port rated at up to 80MB/s
SATA = SATA port rated at up to 150MB/s
SATA2 = SATA II port rated at up to 300MB/s

According to them Sata is the quickest: BUT does this speed transfer through with a eSATA expresscard adapter?
Anyone with a good video editing setup with a Macbook Pro please let me know :D THANKS
I posted this in the Video forum as well, I didnt know which would be a better place for this!
 

SMM

macrumors 65816
Sep 22, 2006
1,334
0
Tiger Mountain - WA State
gman71882 said:
What would be the Quickest External Drive setup for a 15" Macbook Pro?
This will be used for Video editing. (FCP, Imovie, After effects):

External SATA2 HD with a Firewire 800 express card/34?
OR
External SATA2 HD with a eSATA express card/34 :confused:

Some sites list the fw/800 transfer speed @ upto 800 mb/s while others list it as 80 mb/s
sataII is supposed to be 3.0GB/s but ive found it listed as 300MB/s on some sites???? Who is correct?
I can get a eSATA Express card from FirmteK

CoolDrives.com
lists speeds like this:
USB2 = USB 2.0 port rated at 48MB/s
1394a FW400 = FireWire 400 port rated at up to 40MB/s
1394b FW800 = FireWire 800 port rated at up to 80MB/s
SATA = SATA port rated at up to 150MB/s
SATA2 = SATA II port rated at up to 300MB/s

According to them Sata is the quickest: BUT does this speed transfer through with a eSATA expresscard adapter?
Anyone with a good video editing setup with a Macbook Pro please let me know :D THANKS
I posted this in the Video forum as well, I didnt know which would be a better place for this!

You might find this interesting. It deals with RAID, but you can deduce much about the technology.

http://www.barefeats.com/hard35.html
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.