iPhone 17 is narrower but thicker and a bit heavier, while the iPhone Air is wider and thinner. Which iPhone do you think would be easier to use one-handed (or in general) if you have small weak hands?
The Air, less strain because it’s lighter, may need a bumper to reduce grip fatigue because it’s thinner.
Either way it’s a personal preference only truly satisfied by trying it at a store
Tried 16 Plus (similar dimensions to an Air) in an Apple Store today, naturally without a case and it was doable, kind of right on the border for me. A 16 without a case was comfortable. Hmmm, what to do . . .
Tried 16 Plus (similar dimensions to an Air) in an Apple Store today, naturally without a case and it was doable, kind of right on the border for me. A 16 without a case was comfortable. Hmmm, what to do . . .
Wait until the 17 series comes out so you can compare.
It's possible the thinness of the Air could help offset for the increased width over the 16/17. However, that's something you'll have to try in-hand before you decide.