Yes visually it would not be a nice gift but it is practical.
Hey Baby! A peace of mind is priceless these days. I also found the best protection your brand new phone can get:
A shiny new WARRANTY!
What you say at the beginning sets the tone my friend
On a serious note, get her an Element Solace. Element cases are kind of like the Chanel of the case world. You can quote me on this.
If you don't mind spending a little more on top, get her a tempered glass screen protector as well. Once you go glass, your phone will look even more bad ass.