Hi Zipur,
I had the same problem. For me it was Booq Vyper vs. Thule Sleeve. I read more than dozen reviews, watched youtube-videos and visited stores.
For me it was like Steve and his choice of furniture for his estate. I was not sure if one of them is "good enough", so I carried my Macbook Pro for nearly a year in a bubble envelope and was very very careful.
To make it short, this summer I got to the store and bought a Booq Vyper.
Really it is magnificent or insanely great. Well build quality and enough cushion. Combination of semi-hard-shell outside and the cushion inside is unique.
The Thule sleeve looks great and in my opinion is more beautiful than the Vyper, but there is no cushion and in most cases, the zipper breaks.
I read it in some reviews on Apple's page, as well as on youtube.
