dferigmu said:
I have recently heard that Belkin and Linksys are the best and that Netgear and D-Link arn't that good. Is that true?
Heh. The first reply to this thread is right - ask a bunch of people and get a bunch of different answers.
Personally, I've had nothing but trouble with Linksys. I have a 802.11b (non-Extreme) Linksys access point / router / 4-port switch. After being on for several days the wireless access slows down considerably, often to the point that I'm getting under 10kB/s transfer speeds. The signal strength remains at the highest level, even though transfer speeds go to hell.
I can't reset it, because then it usually doesn't come back up, leaving me faced with an hour of "pull the plug, put the plug back in, check wireless, no it's not working, pull the plug, put the plug back in ..." Not fun!
We also had a couple of their usb adapters for the Windows machines. One of them always stopped working after a couple months with Win98 and required an OS reinstall (true, the blame lies at least as much in Win98, but everything else was working on that machine). Then it stopped working altogether and no amount of clean installs would make it work again. We moved the usb adapter to a WinXP machine and it worked fine... for about 6 months. Since then it refuses to join the network with WEP enabled, so we either had to disable encryption (bad!) or leave that machine off the network (pain in the butt).
With the Win98 machine, what we did was get a D-Link access point and configured it to work as a wireless bridge to the rest of the network. The Win98's ethernet plugged into the D-Link (so it had no idea it was still 'wireless') and it just worked flawlessly. Never had another problem with that machine.
We bought our first house recently and I said enough of this wireless crap!
I've wired every room with multiple ethernet ports, so the only computer that still uses wireless is the iBook for roaming around the house. The above problems with the Linksys access point still apply. Since the D-Link is no longer in use, I'm thinking of swapping it out and using the Linksys only as a 100mbps switch.
So far I've had lots of good luck with D-Link (also got a gigabit switch and a gigabit card for the FreeBSD machine, it and the Power Mac love their new speed
) and very little with Linksys. But that's only one anecdote, and your experience may be totally different!