I have had a Casemate Naked Tough, a Modal dual layer from Best Buy, and today just finally broke down and bought an Otterbox. I was switching back and forth between the clear and modal cases because I liked them for different reasons, liked the clear because it wasn't at all bulky and you could see the gold phone but didn't like it because the bumper was looking dirty, then I dropped it in the parking lot yesterday and now it's cracked. The other thing I didn't like about it was it was kind of slick to hold. The Modal was nice and grippy to hold and have good coverage on the edges but the entire bottom of the case was exposed, I never really liked that. Now I have the Otterbox, while this is not my first Otterbox it is my first Commuter. I was surprised to find that the opening for the Apple logo isn't covered. It is also very slippery so I am slightly worried about dropping it and it's really hard to get on and off. I guess the verdict is still out but I do like the coverage on the bottom, particularly the plugs covering the lightening port and the headphone jack.