Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Never WhatsApp.

When I tried it some years ago, it would not create an account without access to all my contacts.
So forget it. This is one of the most despicable things an app can do.

You are giving Meta all details of everyone in your contacts. Say you have a friend who needs to use a false name online. Perhaps they are on the run from a violent partner, or government.

Meta can now x-ref the phone number and see their full name and address.

You may need to use a false name on FB. Zuck is sitting there laughing at you because 20 of your friends have already betrayed you by uploading their contacts to Meta.

And Zuck is up to his neck in bl00d with Lavender.

Never allow them access to your contacts.
It is a bit tricky but still possible. You need a clear iPhone with no contacts, thats it. BTW this is how you fool GetContact app for stalking phone numbers – you just have a 2nd phone and add only the contacts you want to find out about.

As for the contacts access, as far as I understand it doesn’t upload them to their servers and doesn’t sync into Facebook profile. Messenger – yes, but not WhatsApp since app was not developed by Facebook originally.

Telegram is much more evil in that sense, stores contacts and all the chats in the cloud (except encrypted which you need to explicitly create and person you communicate with must accept the secret chat invitation) and synced them thru your devices. Sometimes it even fails to delete them and re-synces them back to the device.

Whats good about WhatsApp is that when you delete an app from the phone, entering the same phone number and re-signing into app leads you into void and creates a fresh new account. Literally “what happens on your device stays on your device”, with exception of the devices of people you send messages to.

Even if they can x-ref, nothing holds you from NOT using or creating Facebook or Instagram. Or you can do what I did: create fake profile with one of physical sim cards. I even fooled facebook when they suspected my profile is fake: I stole Arstechnica selfie that they generated with AI, edited it a bit to look like a selfie from old smartphone, replaced exif and Facebook took it as a brand new coin. Profile works, I use it to browse groups and watch “shorts” or how do they call their videos
 
  • Like
Reactions: x86dude
After spending over four years trying to get my friends and family to switch to iMessage, I finally gave up and went back to using WhatsApp full-time. One major reason is iMessage's terrible storage management. Have you ever tried deleting attachments there? It’s an absolute nightmare. On WhatsApp, I can just click "Select All," then "Delete All," and it even gives me the option to delete all copies. iMessage has nothing like that. You STILL need to tap on each damn photo in an endless list of photos, not even a swipe down option to mass select attachments.

Plus, WhatsApp offers features iMessage lacks, like custom wallpapers, status and a one-time viewing option for photos (so I’m not stuck with every screenshot or memes permanently saved).
Also WhatsApp is just plain simpler than iMessage. Idk how people in US use it, in Europe writing to iMessage often feels like violating someone’s private space🤣 people literally receive SMS here
 
Officially WhatsApp isn't GDPR compliant (it uploads contacts to Meta servers in the USA), in practice most people ignore that. There is a WhatsApp for Business, if you have any business contacts on your phone, otherwise your employer could end up in hot water...

We tend to use Signal, which is the underlying protocol for WhatsApp anyway, but it only uploads a hash of the contacts' numbers, to see if they are on the service, as opposed to all of the contact information.
Some of the EU resolutions just fail to work unless they take an action. For example it is forbidden to add water to grape juice to make more wine and sell it as commercial wine, nevertheless lots of Italian and French producers do just that and cite that they have very sugary grapes or not so much grape juice out of them. I doubt EU can or even wants to fine all these producers, golden goose lays the golden eggs and customers seem not to care about reduced flavors or less tannins, everyone is happy
 
Never WhatsApp.

When I tried it some years ago, it would not create an account without access to all my contacts.
So forget it. This is one of the most despicable things an app can do.

Several clubs/hobby groups I've joined use WhatsApp so I "had" to install it. However, I never gave it access to my contacts. It's possible and I don't recall it being hard.

However, if you don't give them access to your contacts, you can't lookup people's contact info in the app to send them a message. At some point communications software needs to know something about the person you are trying to contact to contact them.

Never allow them access to your contacts.

Agree -- I have no interest in my contacts going to Facebook but not Apple either. Generally the more a software/service wants my contacts or similar the less I want them to have it.

Though at this point Microsoft gets quite a bit of them and a lot of other stuff via LinkedIn...
 
  • Like
Reactions: x86dude
Given the ubiquity of WhatsApp outside of the US, are moves like this a primary decision driver for upgrading?
 
I deleted WhatsApp after Apple introduced RCS with iOS 18. Most of the people I message have iPhone's so we iMessage. And the few that don't, we are able to use RCS. For me personally I see little point in using a third party app, when I have the included Messages app that now gives me all the same messaging functionality.
 
Never WhatsApp.

When I tried it some years ago, it would not create an account without access to all my contacts.
So forget it. This is one of the most despicable things an app can do.

You are giving Meta all details of everyone in your contacts. Say you have a friend who needs to use a false name online. Perhaps they are on the run from a violent partner, or government.

Meta can now x-ref the phone number and see their full name and address.

You may need to use a false name on FB. Zuck is sitting there laughing at you because 20 of your friends have already betrayed you by uploading their contacts to Meta.

And Zuck is up to his neck in bl00d with Lavender.

Never allow them access to your contacts.
User error.

I didn't give it access to my contacts.
 
It is just a simple messaging app. It is ridiculous that it drops support for older phones.

It is not “just a simple messaging app”, besides they are not really dropping support for older phones, they are dropping support for the versions of iOS that those phones are able to operate with.
It that really surprising?
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Victor Mortimer
Anyone know why in EU it seems nearly everyone uses WhatsApp whilst in U.S. that is not the case? 🤔
 
Some of the EU resolutions just fail to work unless they take an action. For example it is forbidden to add water to grape juice to make more wine and sell it as commercial wine, nevertheless lots of Italian and French producers do just that and cite that they have very sugary grapes or not so much grape juice out of them. I doubt EU can or even wants to fine all these producers, golden goose lays the golden eggs and customers seem not to care about reduced flavors or less tannins, everyone is happy
The problem is, they'd have to go against individuals and it just isn't worth the time or money. When an employee uses WhatsApp on a personal device and has their business contact list on the phone as well, that can get the company into hot water, if they are audited and it is found out...

But they can't go after WhatsApp itself, as it is the use of WhatsApp that is the problem, not that WhatsApp exists...
 
business-wise, European business people use the app. From here on, I am not sure what will do now.
Literally everybody uses WhatsApp. I've lived in 4 EU countries and everybody uses WhatsApp. It's impossible to find someone who'd use iMessage, even when they have an iPhone and they refuse to use iMessage.
I feel like a lot of people don't understand it on here. You can't make people switch to another messaging app either.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Victor Mortimer
Literally everybody uses WhatsApp. I've lived in 4 EU countries and everybody uses WhatsApp. It's impossible to find someone who'd use iMessage, even when they have an iPhone and they refuse to use iMessage.
I feel like a lot of people don't understand it on here. You can't make people switch to another messaging app either.
Many don't understand I have 5 messaging apps for clients around the world. This app has an impact on us here who use the app with euro people. Viber is used also, but not to the extent of WhatsApp
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Victor Mortimer
Can you please clarify the reasons for your statement?
Here in the UK and EU it has become a rather essential service.

By the way, the service is called WhatsApp, and not What'sCrapp.
Honestly, it's just not the App for me, secondly I personally prefer iMessage over WhatsApp, because for the lack of support on the iPad, for instance.
 
Outside USA, WhatsApp is a must or you are simply disconnected.
That's simply not possible unless you're all using phones without cell service.

SMS still exists, you can't turn it off. And if somebody has an iPhone, it's gonna default to using iMessage if available, and you'd have to actively turn it off.

Sorry, that's just nonsense.
 
I don’t think he meant literally disconnected, rather you’ll be left out of a lot of WhatsApp group chats etc, which really are totally ubiquitous over here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big_D
That's simply not possible unless you're all using phones without cell service.

SMS still exists, you can't turn it off. And if somebody has an iPhone, it's gonna default to using iMessage if available, and you'd have to actively turn it off.

Sorry, that's just nonsense.

Let me reword it for you:

Outside of the USA (specifically in the EU and UK) WhatsApp is so ubiquitous that if you don't have it on your phone and don't use it, you are not as well connected as everyone else is.
Yes, of course you can still communicate with people with other services, but A: Other people might not want to communicate that way, and B: You would not be able to access the numerous WhatsApp group communications so commonly used here, or C: You would not be accessible for audio/video communication everyone here conduct on WhatsApp when done cross borders (to save on call cost) or when performed from phones other than iPhones (not everyone has FaceTime). Yes, there are other apps doing the same thing, but everyone here use WhatsApp and nobody is going to change it by complaining (or by reacting to posts with Angry emojis). It is not hard to understand why it has become pretty much an essential service.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big_D
Let me reword it for you:

Outside of the USA (specifically in the EU and UK) WhatsApp is so ubiquitous that if you don't have it on your phone and don't use it, you are not as well connected as everyone else is.
Yes, of course you can still communicate with people with other services, but A: Other people might not want to communicate that way, and B: You would not be able to access the numerous WhatsApp group communications so commonly used here, or C: You would not be accessible for audio/video communication everyone here conduct on WhatsApp when done cross borders (to save on call cost) or when performed from phones other than iPhones (not everyone has FaceTime). Yes, there are other apps doing the same thing, but everyone here use WhatsApp and nobody is going to change it by complaining (or by reacting to posts with Angry emojis). It is not hard to understand why it has become pretty much an essential service.
Unfortunately true, although my family uses Signal, one daughter uses WhatsApp as well. My wife uses Threema for business at work.

My eldest daughter only uses it for the kindergarten, but nothing else.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.