Which 10 Stop ND Filter

Discussion in 'Digital Photography' started by TheDrift-, Nov 6, 2012.

  1. TheDrift- macrumors 6502a


    Mar 8, 2010
    I was thinking of getting a cheap 10 stop ND filter to throw in my bag and experiment with.

    I understand that the B & W filters & cokin z filters are well thought of but the daddy of them all is the lee big stopper.

    The problem with the screw in filters is that its dark to compose your scene where as with the drop in type you can compose normally then drop in the filter.

    I have a passable knowledge of curves and colour theory and think I should be able to correct a slight colour cast (as long as its consistent)

    Is t worth buying a cheaper filter to see how I get on...or will i end up buying twice? Are Lee filters worth the money or would something cheaper suit my needs.

    Any recommendations?
  2. Phrasikleia, Nov 6, 2012
    Last edited: Mar 3, 2013

    Phrasikleia macrumors 601


    Feb 24, 2008
    Over there------->
    I wasn't aware that Cokin has a 10-stop filter, but I can comment on the B&W and Lee. You've probably heard that each has a cast (blue with the Lee and magenta with the B&W), so choose your poison. They do require some color correction, but it doesn't get really bad unless you start stacking other filters on top of them.

    I researched them both myself and went for the B&W. The Lee filter has foam edges that provide a fairly snug fit, and from what I understand it can be difficult to get it in and out of the holder without jiggling your camera. That might not be a problem for most people, but if you like to combine exposures, it's something to consider. With the B&W, I can screw it on lightly and remove it easily without jiggling anything. I have the 77mm filter and a step-up ring so that I can use it on a 67mm thread as well; six of my lenses are one of those two sizes, so I'm covered for pretty much anything.

    As for metering, I just use an iPhone app called ND Calc. First I get the right shutter speed with the filter off, then I gently screw on the filter, calculate with the app, and take a test shot. If the exposure isn't right, then I just move the app's shutter speed dial accordingly and try again. I never need to take the filter off again just for metering.

    Here are few long exposures I've taken with the B&W:

    Summer Breeze


    In the Moment

    If you look carefully, you might be able to pick up on the magenta cast in these, since I often choose to leave it to some extent. I see a lot of people using the Big Stopper who likewise leave some of the cool blue cast in their photos, so like I said, you just have to choose which way you want your photos to lean. I like how the magenta adds to the effects of a sunset, but some people prefer cooler, steely colors.

    Again, I don't know anything about the really cheap filters you speak of, but I would avoid them. If you really just want to play around with long exposures for little to nothing in the way of investment, you might consider a piece of welding glass from eBay, which will cost you only about five bucks. If you google it, you'll find some interesting threads with attachment advice and eBay seller tips.
  3. TheDrift- thread starter macrumors 6502a


    Mar 8, 2010
    Thanks cokin has an 8 stop not a 10 stop my bad...they do a kit with a holder a 2, 4 and 8 stop nd filter in their z pro line for £136 which seems pretty good value...well compared to the lee which is £156 for the 10 stopper alone!

    ..thanks for the tip on the app :)

    I guess I was just drawn to Lee as thats the one that gets mentioned all the time, I would rather a warm cast than a cold one tho.
  4. MCAsan macrumors 601


    Jul 9, 2012
    Personally I like a variable ND. I shoot around woodland streams very often where a fixed ND can easily bee too strong. With my LightCraft VND I can dial in from 2-8 stops of light reduction.
  5. nburwell macrumors 68040


    May 6, 2008
    I wouldn't recommend buying a cheap 10-stop filter at all. I mean, you will still get acceptable images, but you will probably have to spend more time in LR or PS cleaning up the image than you would if you invested in a quality filter.

    With that said, I have a B+W 10-stop filter which I purchased for $125. It is worth every penny.
  6. fcortese macrumors demi-god


    Apr 3, 2010
    Big Sky country
    P is the ND filter expert, IMO. Here is a nice review article that I stumbled upon when trying to figure out if I wanted to add any of these filters to my camera bag. I had a .9 Tiffen ND screw on and a Lee GND filter. I eventually bought an inexpensive Vivatar VND filter (ND2 to ND 1000) for about US$ 42. I figured, I'd give it a try and if it didn't work out I'd only be out less that $50. So far it has worked fine.
  7. TheDrift-, Nov 6, 2012
    Last edited: Nov 6, 2012

    TheDrift- thread starter macrumors 6502a


    Mar 8, 2010
    Initially I was leaning towards the Lee, but figure I might get the B&W, its pretty cheap for the 77 (relatively!) this will fit a lot of lenses of mine..and the others are 67mm.

    ...it might be a problem if i can ever stretch to the 24 70 2.8 II (although that would be a nice problem to have :))

    Is there a lot of difference between the single coat and multi coat varieties?
  8. AxisOfBeagles macrumors 6502


    Apr 22, 2008
    East of Shangrila
    I use the 9-stop Hoya HMC ND400 (the 82mm version is mentioned in that very good article you linked fcortese - thanks for that).

    I've had no significant issues with color cast (then again, I probably correct for it in post without thinking about it), nor do I find the screw-in to be a problem. For shots using heavy ND filters, I always compose and focus without the filter on, set it all to manual, then place the filter on carefully. Exposure is usually determined by an external incident meter, a "EV calculator" (just a piece of card with equivalent EV values) and then bracketed around my target exposure.

    $86 from Amazon, I've considered the Hoya to be a quality filter at a good price.

  9. spacedcadet macrumors regular

    Mar 5, 2009

    I got a cheap Agfa 8 stop variable for £25 on Amazon. Not done loads with it so far, but seems to work OK and for the price is a decent product to test with.

Share This Page