Which is better: Portenzo, Pad and Quill, DODOCase or Treegloo?

[Himynamesnoah]

I've been looking into getting a book style case for my new iPad (3rd Generation). I want to stay around $60, but I keep seeing negative things about DODO and Portenzo, and can't really find a good comparison of the cases.

So if someone could please help me out, that would be great.

 

[glen e]

I've been looking into getting a book style case for my new iPad (3rd Generation). I want to stay around $60, but I keep seeing negative things about DODO and Portenzo, and can't really find a good comparison of the cases.

So if someone could please help me out, that would be great.

I've owned them all and they all suck - read why I think so here:


https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1346676/

 

[toxictrix]

I had a Tree-gloo and returned it. It was loose and the cloth backing was fraying badly within a week of use.

 

[drew0020]

I've owned both the portenzo and dodocase. Both are very nice cases. I never had problems with either (just got the Portenzo for the new iPad) so its only been a week. My iPad usually sits in my coffee table though. If you are constantly taking the iPad on trips, to work, or school, etc I can see either of these cases warping over time.

 

[yokunai]

I agree.

 

[blacksurf]

I use Pad And Quill - I have a new Oxford Dark Tan one to sell if anyone is interested (UK Only)