Which keyboard?

The second one is wireless so that might be the difference that makes the difference. I use that keyboard with my external monitor and a magic trackpad when I use my MBP in clamshell mode with an external. At first it took a bit to get used to it but now it is fine.

 

i love the full sized wired keyboard that Apple currently sells. i can't stand the compressed wireless one. I don't wanna feel like i'm typing on a laptop when using my imac...
I'd love to see a wireless version of the full size one though. also backlit keys would be nice.

The older style keyboards seem to be liked by quite a few people. My mom loves the old clackity IBM keyboard my brother has, but I prefer my sleek aluminium one.