Well said! I get so tired of seeing the financial advice lectures!
The way I see it, it's not that people are being rude and trying to enforce their supremacy or anything.
Actually quite the contrary, people with personal experience are taking time to help advice a younger fella out. It is not uncommon for people to have their cars seized, or houses foreclosed... Selling debt is the Bank's greatest MO.
Fellow board members are advising a young man based on their experience, and maturity. And they are doing it out of goodwill and goodfaith. There is no impact of them whatsoever, what OP decides to buy.
Op shouldn't ask them to shut up. Some of us are way older than the 'just going to college' students that are just entering college. We know the pressure that comes with college life. The social impact, and so on.
OP should just read it through, and if he is still convinced to buy a Mac he most certainly should. Asking people who are trying to help, to shut up, isn't a very response to courtesy being shown by fellow board members.
Just my 2 cents.
But if OP a Macabook w/o doubt, I would say go for the base. There are a lot of hidden expenses. - Apple Care, cables, case...
I myself got the 8b/256, which costed me $1500 here... but then there's another $300 for Apple care (cost that much here), I have spend $70 on 2 adapters, $100 on external memory, and $80 for a sleeve.
All in all a $1500 Mac Air has cost me about $2100. Factor in another $100 that I'm going to spend on 128gb SD card, and $100 down the road for battery replacement which i expect in 2 years (my laptop is never plugged, except when charging).
That's now $2300
For apps - essentials already bought: $250 for Microsoft Office Home and Business.
Parallels for Desktop/Vmware: Currently trying out each, parallels will cost $80 and VMware $50.
Windows 7 Home Premium: $200
That's an additional $500 for my essential apps, bringing the total to $2800. I'm throwing in another $200 for 3 years worth of other apps (which is pretty low).
All in all, that means for this mac to last me 3 years, I will be spending $3000 on a machine that I spent $1500 at Apple Store for.
I factored this before buying my Air. OP should too. The apps are not necessary at all though... so that's about $500 off if not running Windows.
This isn't just a pointer to op, but to everyone reading. Don't forget after-purchase expenses!
Cheers, and have a good day.